OSRI-0001 · Healthcare / Engineering / Informatics / Economics

Medical XR: from capabilities to sustainable use

Mapping how extended reality, interactive 3D and AI capabilities become useful, sustainable medical applications, using published evidence and technology histories.

View materials ↓Find a contribution task ↗

Human lead Cole / @ajhcs

Research status Active · Research

Status updated 2026-11-16

  1. Planning
  2. Research
  3. Writing & review
  4. Publication

The question

Since 2020, has progress from commercial XR and AI capabilities to useful, sustainable medical applications accelerated—and what technical, staffing, financial and organizational conditions enable or constrain further acceleration?
Research checkpoint · source checked 2026-11-17

Provisional model screening is open to contributors. Final PI review follows the completed screening packet. The public archive and 43 tables preserve the frozen 13 November snapshot. Human verification is pending. The study has yet to establish whether progress accelerated.

Methods and limits

An inherited capability evidence map connects technologies, medical tasks, outcomes and adoption conditions. The evolving method and addenda, search-history gaps and proposed measures are public. The 18,976 provisional publication groups are not a count of independent studies; initial agent assessments do not establish final inclusion or accuracy. This is a nonclinical synthesis; it recruits no patients and delivers no care.

Intended outputs and venues

Output plans are proposals for Cole’s review. A selected target records intent; submission, acceptance and publication are separate events. Targets do not count as published outputs.

Candidate—under review

DIGITAL HEALTH

The broad audience fits health-system adoption questions, but the fee discrepancy and policy compatibility need resolution.

Recommendation: Broad-audience alternative for Cole to consider after editor clarification of agent-assisted evidence coding. Candidate—under review; no selection or submission recorded.

Compare scope, methods, fees and AI policy
Audience
Digital-health researchers, clinicians, allied health practitioners, patients, social scientists, industry and government.
Scope
Broad digital-health research and implementation. Potential fit for the map of technical capabilities, medical tasks and organizational sustainability; detailed scope confirmation remains needed.
Article types
Review; Original Research Article; Perspective
Methodological expectations
Review is the relevant provisional route. The guidelines call for critical, comprehensive literature assessment; research articles need explicit methods and results. The inherited map must retain its search gaps and chronology; it cannot yet claim a completed systematic review.
Overlapping work
Deegan et al. (2025), A scoping review of frameworks evaluating digital health applications, DOI 10.1177/20552076251315297, already examines evaluation frameworks and VR deployment. Distinguish the proposed capability-to-task trajectory and staffing, financial and organizational conditions.
Open-access costs
Official sources disagree: submission guidelines list USD 3,400; the Sage journal catalog lists USD 3,200. Budget provisionally at USD 3,400 plus applicable taxes and obtain a current quote. Discounts or waivers depend on eligibility; none is verified for OSRI.
AI disclosure
Disclose generative assistance affecting research or content in Methods or acknowledgments and verify original sources. AI cannot be an author. Ordinary language assistance is exempt. Sage lists analysis of experiences and themes among prohibited uses; ask the editor how the inherited agent-assisted evidence coding fits before selecting this venue.

Verified 2026-11-15

Candidate—under review

Frontiers in Virtual Reality — Virtual Reality in Medicine

Closest specialist readership and a direct precedent for medical-XR implementation work; broader non-XR context and original analyses need a clear article-type fit.

Recommendation: First specialist option for Cole to consider once the intended evidence-synthesis method and scope are agreed. Candidate—under review; no selection or submission recorded.

Compare scope, methods, fees and AI policy
Audience
XR researchers, developers, clinicians and others evaluating medical VR applications.
Scope
Medical applications of VR and related technologies, including clinical or surgical training, access, engagement and care delivery. General AI or 3D technology histories need an explicit medical-XR connection.
Article types
Systematic Review (includes mapping and scoping reviews); Review; Methods; Data Report; Perspective
Methodological expectations
A mapping or scoping review can use the Systematic Review article type, with a defined question, transparent selection, extraction and synthesis, appropriate reporting guidance and study flow. Review and Systematic Review articles must exclude unpublished material. Resolve the status of original technology-history analysis before choosing the article type.
Overlapping work
Morgan, Patel and Campbell (2025), Practical considerations of clinical XR (AR/VR) deployments, DOI 10.3389/frvir.2025.1517402, already covers deployment challenges, institutions and reimbursement. A traceable evidence map should demonstrate what its chronology and source-linked analysis add.
Open-access costs
CHF 2,195 for A-type articles, including Review, Systematic Review and Methods; CHF 1,750 for B-types such as Data Report and Perspective. Fees are payable after acceptance. Institutional support or fee assistance is conditional and unverified for OSRI.
AI disclosure
Disclose generated or edited text/visuals in acknowledgments and Methods when applicable, naming tool, version, model and source. Authors verify factual accuracy, references and originality; AI cannot be an author. Prompts and outputs are encouraged as supplements.

Verified 2026-11-15

Candidate—under review

Journal of Medical Internet Research

Broad visibility for rigorous digital-health synthesis, with substantial competition from existing implementation literature and a demanding contribution test.

Recommendation: Conditional broad-reach option if the final analysis yields strong, generalizable digital-health findings. Candidate—under review; no selection or submission recorded.

Compare scope, methods, fees and AI policy
Audience
An interdisciplinary digital-health, health-informatics and health-services readership.
Scope
Digitally enabled information and communication in health, emphasizing real-world implications. A general XR technology history needs a clear digital-health contribution and generalizable implementation insight.
Article types
Review (systematic or scoping); Original Paper; Viewpoint
Methodological expectations
Review submissions use structured reporting with a study-selection flow, detailed searches and the applicable completed reporting checklist. Review registration is recommended. Valid data, appropriate methods and supported conclusions are selection criteria; a large provisional corpus alone is insufficient.
Overlapping work
Sarkar et al. (2021), Barriers and Facilitators to the Implementation of Virtual Reality as a Pain Management Modality in Academic, Community, and Safety-Net Settings: Qualitative Analysis, DOI 10.2196/26623, covers workflow, resources and reimbursement. Related JMIR XR scoping work (Elser et al., 2024; 10.2196/53129) is in a different journal.
Open-access costs
USD 3,350 standard article processing fee on acceptance; Viewpoint USD 2,680. Applicable taxes and optional services are additional; non-credit-card payments have a 7% surcharge. Institutional or waiver eligibility is unverified.
AI disclosure
The October 2026 policy requires the dedicated AI question at submission and every resubmission; disclosure appears in its own published section, not acknowledgments. Identify tools and outsourced tasks, retain prompts/responses and submit manuscript-preparation conversations as a Multimedia Appendix. Methods still describe AI used in the study. Generated text should be identified in a blockquote, textbox or figure. Human authors remain accountable; no AI authorship.

Verified 2026-11-15

Read the sourced venue comparison →

Public sources and verification dates