Medical XR publication-target comparison
On this page
Project: OSRI-0001 · Official sources checked: 15 November 2026 · All three venues: Candidate—under review.
For Cole's selection, consider Frontiers in Virtual Reality—Virtual Reality in Medicine first for a specialist audience. DIGITAL HEALTH is a broad implementation alternative, subject to clarification of its AI policy and conflicting fee information. Journal of Medical Internet Research (JMIR) is a conditional option if the final analysis supports a strong, generalizable digital-health contribution. These are editorial-fit recommendations inferred from the sources below. No venue is selected, and no submission, acceptance or publication is recorded.
What the project can plan#
The public project record proposes a traceable map connecting technical capabilities, medical tasks, outcomes and conditions for sustainable adoption. Its methods record describes an inherited, evolving evidence map. It is not retrospective registration.
Screening remains PAUSED_BY_HUMAN. There is no acceleration finding or documented human-verified evidence record. Search provenance, full-text selection, report families and deeper extraction remain unresolved. See the saved checkpoint. This comparison authorizes no restart.
The proposed principal output is an evidence-synthesis manuscript supported by the source-linked map, documented methods and permitted data/code. Cole must confirm its final review design and contribution. A formal systematic or scoping review label requires the corresponding work and reporting; the current corpus does not establish that status. The three journals are alternatives for that manuscript, not three promised publications. Supporting materials are not automatically separate publication records.
Audience, scope and possible article route#
| Candidate—under review | Audience and fit | Relevant eligible types |
|---|---|---|
| DIGITAL HEALTH | Broad digital-health and health-system readership. Potential fit for adoption, resources and organizational conditions. The full aims-and-scope endpoint was inaccessible; this assessment uses the official journal description and published work. | Review, Original Research Article, Perspective. Review is the provisional route. |
| Frontiers in Virtual Reality—Virtual Reality in Medicine | Specialist medical-XR readership; the section scope includes training, access, engagement and care delivery. Wider AI/3D histories need a clear medical-XR connection. | Systematic Review, Review, Methods, Data Report, Perspective. Mapping and scoping reviews fall within Systematic Review. |
| Journal of Medical Internet Research | Interdisciplinary digital-health, informatics and health-services readers. The current scope emphasizes real-world implications of digital enablement; a general technology history needs a stronger connection. | Review, Original Paper, Viewpoint. Systematic or scoping Review is the provisional route. |
Methods and existing overlap#
DIGITAL HEALTH expects a critical, comprehensive Review and clear methods for research articles. Deegan et al.'s A scoping review of frameworks evaluating digital health applications (2025; DOI 10.1177/20552076251315297) already connects evaluation frameworks with digital-health and VR deployment. Medical XR should show what its capability-to-task chronology and sustainability evidence add.
Frontiers specifies transparent review methods, appropriate reporting guidance and study flow. Its Review and Systematic Review types exclude unpublished material; a manuscript combining literature synthesis with original technology-history analysis needs article-type clarification. Morgan, Patel and Campbell's Practical considerations of clinical XR (AR/VR) deployments (2025; DOI 10.3389/frvir.2025.1517402) already addresses institutional, technical and reimbursement challenges. A new map needs traceable evidence and a distinct contribution beyond that perspective.
JMIR requires applicable reporting checklists and transparent review methods; registration is recommended. Its selection criteria require valid data and supported conclusions. Sarkar et al.'s Barriers and Facilitators to the Implementation of Virtual Reality as a Pain Management Modality in Academic, Community, and Safety-Net Settings: Qualitative Analysis (2021; DOI 10.2196/26623) overlaps on workflow, resources and reimbursement.
Additional overlap crosses venue boundaries: Elser et al.'s chronic-pain implementation scoping review (2024; DOI 10.2196/53129) appeared in JMIR XR and Spatial Computing, a different journal. Kouijzer et al.'s Implementation of virtual reality in healthcare: a scoping review on the implementation process of virtual reality in various healthcare settings (2023; DOI 10.1186/s43058-023-00442-2) appeared in Implementation Science Communications. These examples are a bounded overlap check, not a complete novelty search.
Open-access costs#
| Candidate—under review | Official listed fee and unresolved conditions |
|---|---|
| DIGITAL HEALTH | Submission guidelines: USD 3,400. Sage catalog: USD 3,200. The discrepancy remains unresolved. Use USD 3,400 provisionally and obtain a current quote. |
| Frontiers | Fee schedule: CHF 2,195 for A-types, including Review, Systematic Review and Methods; CHF 1,750 for B-types such as Perspective and Data Report. |
| JMIR | Fee schedule: USD 3,350 standard; USD 2,680 for Viewpoint. Applicable taxes, optional services and a 7% non-credit-card payment surcharge may add costs. |
These are listed acceptance-stage charges, not approved budgets or binding quotes. Institutional support, discounts and waivers depend on eligibility; none has been verified for OSRI. Recheck fees and obtain the responsible person's authorization before incurring costs.
AI disclosure and policy fit#
Under Sage's journal policy, generative assistance affecting research or content requires disclosure and source verification; ordinary language assistance is exempt. AI cannot be an author. Prohibited uses include analysis of experiences and themes. Cole should clarify how the inherited agent-assisted evidence coding fits before choosing DIGITAL HEALTH. The book-author AI policy is a separate policy and was not used here.
Frontiers' policy calls for disclosure in acknowledgments and Methods when applicable, including tool, version, model and source. Human authors must check accuracy and originality. AI authorship is excluded; supplying prompts and outputs is encouraged.
JMIR's policy, updated 23 October 2026, uses a dedicated question at submission and every resubmission. The published AI disclosure has its own section; it should not be duplicated in acknowledgments. The policy requests retained prompts/responses and manuscript-preparation conversations as a Multimedia Appendix. Methods still explain AI used in the study. Generated text should be identified in a blockquote, textbox or figure. This newer process changes the disclosure location described in the 2023 editorial.
Selection record#
Cole's selection remains pending. Confirm the review design, contribution, human verification plan, article type, policy compatibility and funding before selecting a target. No editor has been contacted and no fee eligibility has been confirmed.
The structured publication targets retain official sources and check dates. A later selected target must record Cole's decision and date. Target selection remains separate from submission, acceptance, public output registration and contributor-activity counts.
Research and source checks for this comparison were performed by a Codex agent on 15 November 2026. Human scientific and editorial review remain pending. Publisher policies can change before submission.