Tellurium: a Calzone model archive and a paper-figure comparison
On this page
Execute the exact COMBINE archive cited in Figure4 and reference54 of Medley et al. (2018). It packages the Calzone2007 Drosophila model plus two SED-ML simulations. The author repository's former demos/ path moved to real-models/; the source manifest pins commiteff025846c5b12ee4350f043623332158e05f262 and the archive hash.
Repeat the run#
micromamba create -y -p ./env -f environment.yml
./env/bin/python fetch_sources.py
LD_LIBRARY_PATH="$PWD/env/lib" MPLBACKEND=Agg ./env/bin/python run_calzone.py --output ./run
LD_LIBRARY_PATH="$PWD/env/lib" ./env/bin/python compare_calzone.py --run ./run --output ./comparison
requirements-tested.txt and environment-explicit.txt record tested Python3.11/Tellurium2.2.13.1 dependencies. This is a current runtime rather than the paper-era environment. On this Linux conda runtime, libRoadRunner needed the environment's lib directory in LD_LIBRARY_PATH; Tellurium also required the undeclared six dependency. Those corrections affect the isolated runtime only.
The archive and its SBML/SED-ML are unchanged. executeCombineArchive runs the original and String-turnover variants with KiSAO0000019, each with1000 intervals(1001 samples), ending at250 and180 model-time units. The variant changes ksstg to0.02,kdstg to0.015 and initialStgPc to0, matching the article's described changes. All21 exported data-generators were finite. The SBML has a unit definition named min but no explicit model-level timeUnits attribute; outputs retain model-time units without an imposed conversion.
Comparison to Figure4B#
Before any archive execution,10 Wee1c points were selected from the published Figure4B image at times25,50,75,100,125,145,180,200,220 and240. Pixel calibration and the rule are in digitization-protocol.json. The bounds RMSE<=0.03 and maximum absolute error<=0.06 in model concentration units were chosen to allow figure line thickness/calibration and current deterministic-solver differences. These are OSRI comparison bounds, not tolerances published by the authors.
| Target | Observed | Bound | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wee1c RMSE,10 selected points | 0.00267333 | 0.03 | Within bound |
| Wee1c maximum absolute error | 0.00626005 | 0.06 | Within bound |
The comparison covers the selected Figure4B Wee1c trace. It does not establish agreement for all six panels, all parameters, the original BIOCHAM implementation, or biological prediction. Full SED-ML arrays and six generated plots remain retained. The compact CSV includes the entire1001-sample Figure4B trajectories; comparison-points.csv gives paper values, computed values and residuals. The paper's reference figure is open access under CC BY terms; the original archive/model retain their own source and attribution terms and are fetched rather than relicensed here.
The first export wrapper missed the nested dataGenerators dictionary; the archive itself executed. That partial export is retained, and the corrected export wrapper reruns the unchanged archive. See the run record and setup-attempt notes.
Status: Selected paper target compared within predeclared bounds using author archive/current runtime. Human scientific review of digitization, tolerance and scope is pending; no blanket reproduction of the full paper is claimed.
Reference-helper packaging check#
The original 10 reference points and tolerance protocol were generated by the working one-off digitize_references.py before any archive execution. The standalone digitize_reference.py was derived later for this portable bundle. Its first packaged copy lost a comment marker and failed to parse; that broken copy is retained as a packaging failure. Adding the marker fixed syntax only. The corrected helper ran in a fresh directory and regenerated the original 10-point CSV and protocol byte for byte. See packaging-validation.json for source and result hashes. No target, calibration, tolerance or model output changed.
Download the recorded files#
- raw-results.npz — All21 executed SEDML data-generators.
- figure4b-traces.csv — Complete1001-sample Figure4B model traces.
- comparison-points.csv — 10 fixed paper/computed Wee1c pairs and residuals.
- comparison.png — Selected paper/model Wee1c overlay.
- comparison.json — Scoped prospective comparison receipt.
- guide.md — portable driver or environment/source record.
- source-manifest.json — portable driver or environment/source record.
- fetch_sources.py — portable driver or environment/source record.
- environment.yml — portable driver or environment/source record.
- environment-explicit.txt — portable driver or environment/source record.
- requirements-tested.txt — portable driver or environment/source record.
- setup-attempts.json — portable driver or environment/source record.
- compact-run-record.json — portable driver or environment/source record.
- digitize_reference.py — portable driver or environment/source record.
- run-record.json — portable driver or environment/source record.
- run_calzone.py — portable driver or environment/source record.
- compare_calzone.py — portable driver or environment/source record.
- paper-figure4b-wee1c-digitized.csv — portable driver or environment/source record.
- digitization-protocol.json — portable driver or environment/source record.
- packaging-validation.json — portable driver or environment/source record.
Complete run record · All candidate attempts. Human scientific review is pending.