Compare the authors’ SimGrid coordinator-worker models
On this page
Casanova et al. (2025) compare simulator time and memory in Section 7, Figures 13–14. Their open manuscript, introductory paragraph before Section 2, explicitly calls SimGrid 3.10 “v3” and describes development through 3.36, culminating in v4. Reference 66 links the coordinator-worker benchmark, whose Dockerfiles select 3.10 and 3.36.
This example runs those author implementations at the lower and upper workload anchors of Figure 13. The source pins are benchmark b09453d19541b7186703f4d651c1bba790461e44, SimGrid 3.10 9a82cac1b6f73bb342495c39807acd7380e153d5, and SimGrid 3.36 7ed73b43153fc79a8c5eb5cff8e9f81e4f52e619. It does not establish that 3.36 is the exact unnamed development commit used for every plotted paper observation.
Construct and run#
Use Linux, Python 3 with venv, git, GCC/G++, GNU time, and a compiler-compatible Boost prefix. The build harness and pinned build requirements keep downloads, builds and temporary XML inputs inside the example folder. Set BOOST_ROOT to the selected Boost prefix, then run:
bash build-network-tools.sh
SIMGRID_DEPENDENCY_PREFIX="$BOOST_ROOT" python3 run_simgrid.py
python3 analyse_simgrid.py
The SimGrid runner independently writes simgrid-output/runs.json and its makespan-comparison receipt. Run into a fresh output folder; preserve an earlier run when repeating.
The build applies the exact CMake workaround in the authors’ Dockerfile_simgrid_v3_10, runs that old configure from its build directory, and changes two hardcoded /tmp XML filenames to the local temporary folder. Numerical model/event logic is unchanged. Both simulator builds use the same GCC 13.3 compiler and optimization level on Ubuntu 24.04. The article used Debian 12 and a dedicated Intel Xeon Platinum 8380 core; this run used one pinned CPU in a shared host. Timing differences therefore remain descriptive local measurements. Primary wall time comes from GNU time -v, matching the author driver; Python subprocess-wrapper elapsed is retained separately and includes launch/wait overhead.
Each simulated platform contains 1,000 four-core worker hosts, 100 network links, routes of 10 links, 100–200 Mflop/s core speeds, and 100–200 MB/s bandwidths. Every workunit communicates 100 MB and computes 100 Mflop. The 3.36 run enables host-energy simulation as the authors’ driver does. The lower/upper workloads are 4,000 and 60,000 workunits, with ten seeds per version per workload. Intermediate Figure 13 points and the Figure 14 core-count sweep remain unexecuted.
Before timing, three small fixed-seed cases check both models’ makespans. A separate paper-size 4,000-workunit check compares native completion timestamps. The predeclared tolerance is 0.000001 simulated seconds, reflecting the native log resolution; it is a local consistency rule, not a published paper tolerance.
Inspect the outputs#
Replication-level measurements, summaries, and the complete comparison retain all ten runs and native makespan checks. Error bars in the supplied endpoint figure are minimum/maximum over repetitions.
| Workunits | SimGrid 3.10 mean peak RSS | SimGrid 3.36 mean peak RSS | Local RSS ratio | Local wall-time ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4,000 | 354,393.6 KiB | 68,160 KiB | 5.1994 | 1.2995 |
| 60,000 | 365,107.2 KiB | 68,160 KiB | 5.3566 | 1.5847 |
All four native makespan comparisons matched exactly. At 1,000 hosts and 4,000 workunits, seed 0, both reported 4,233.049287 simulated seconds. The local RSS ratios exceed the paper’s reported minimum 4.1 reduction, while the local wall-time ratio at the lower endpoint is below its reported minimum 1.45. These are two endpoint observations on a different host/compiler; the complete historical curves and hardware speedups are not claimed reproduced.
The source programs carry SimGrid-team LGPL notices; the associated SimGrid package identifies LGPL-2.1 with separate component notices. Retrieve source through the pinned harness and preserve those notices. Do not apply OSRI’s original-code license to third-party model code. Human scientific review remains pending.
Download the recorded files#
- comparison.json — numerical comparison receipt.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- figure13-endpoints.png — original comparison figure.
- figure13-endpoints.svg — original comparison figure.
- performance-replications.csv — numerical result.
- performance-summary.csv — numerical result.
- runs.json — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- platform_master_worker.xml — native generated simulation input.
- platform_master_worker_d.xml — native generated simulation input.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- platform_master_worker.xml — native generated simulation input.
- platform_master_worker_d.xml — native generated simulation input.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- platform_master_worker.xml — native generated simulation input.
- platform_master_worker_d.xml — native generated simulation input.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- platform_master_worker.xml — native generated simulation input.
- platform_master_worker_d.xml — native generated simulation input.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- platform_master_worker.xml — native generated simulation input.
- platform_master_worker_d.xml — native generated simulation input.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- platform_master_worker.xml — native generated simulation input.
- platform_master_worker_d.xml — native generated simulation input.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- platform_master_worker.xml — native generated simulation input.
- platform_master_worker_d.xml — native generated simulation input.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- platform_master_worker.xml — native generated simulation input.
- platform_master_worker_d.xml — native generated simulation input.
- run.json — native run output or command record.
- stderr.log — native run output or command record.
- stdout.log — native run output or command record.
- compact-simgrid-record.json — portable compact run/comparison receipt.
- build-network-tools.sh — portable driver or environment/source record.
- requirements-build.txt — portable driver or environment/source record.
- THIRD-PARTY-NOTICES.md — portable driver or environment/source record.
- targets-before-run.json — portable driver or environment/source record.
- plot_network_results.py — portable driver or environment/source record.
- requirements-plot.txt — portable driver or environment/source record.
- simgrid-guide.md — portable driver or environment/source record.
- run_simgrid.py — portable driver or environment/source record.
- analyse_simgrid.py — portable driver or environment/source record.
Complete run record · All candidate attempts. Human scientific review is pending.