deal.II

On this page

All candidate attempts · Simulation Lab

Can a coupled fluid/structure solve recover the published FSI3 oscillation and force observables?

Execution: Attempted; blocked. Paper comparison: not established. Human scientific review is pending.

Paper and author code#

Proposal for Numerical Benchmarking of Fluid-Structure Interaction between an Elastic Object and Laminar Incompressible Flow (10.1007/3-540-34596-5_15). Publication type: book-chapter.

Paper location: Original 2006 FSI3 benchmark; maintained tutorial also cites the 2010 extension DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-14206-2_8. Historical reference/constitutive alignment unresolved; no original result comparison.

Source; ref: v202211.0; commit: 0482e5b4d3e1604dd031d2b113a2aaa63733c9a8.

Source files: turek-hron-fsi3/precice-config.xml; turek-hron-fsi3/fluid-openfoam/run.sh; turek-hron-fsi3/solid-dealii/run.sh; turek-hron-fsi3/solid-dealii/parameters.prm

Terms: preCICE tutorials LGPL-3.0; solver and adapter licenses separately apply

Relationship to the paper: Maintainer implementation of the literature benchmark; this tool supplies the nonlinear solid solver. Both preCICE and deal.II records refer to one coupled experiment. Exact historical case equivalence and the scientific target remain unresolved.

Inputs and environment#

description: FSI3 geometry, fluid/solid constitutive parameters, inlet ramp, mesh, time step and XML coupling settings from pinned case.; access: Case/meshes public. Author FSI3 reference series retrieved (1,113,417bytes; SHA256c428bc3ff48c1698cd10aacf0941cba6aabdfcb9d61c8b7e42c343f381434e63); this is upstream data, not a local simulation.; hashes: qualification-cg/precice-config.xml: 924518a5fa58a2ee1eaec42a8eaedb527adeaf7b0ae5f700b5179abbe01b8c68; qualification-cg/solid-dealii/parameters.prm: b5dd918bcb97daa1918f289066c914386a88acab589b10e0c05c823a50541a3d; qualification-cg/fluid-openfoam/0/U: 9c4083af85c05dc489a2a2fb06d9807c44a1beb82b198e8123d774f2fdd5a874; qualification-cg/fluid-openfoam/system/fvSolution: a0d399eaba95fbe39a0d1cd3aeb2eb4a0a834312772354cc0c553e22d2752d75; qualification-tight/fluid-openfoam/system/fvSolution: 01990053fa8dd2adf52a30c86bbf20ec392c17d610b9ddc4c154f891f9564396

versions: boost-cpp: 1.74.0; cmake: 3.27.9; dealii: 9.3.2; openmpi: 4.1.6; petsc: 3.17.4; precice: 2.5.0; openfoam: OpenCFD2412; compiler: GCC13.3.0; changes_from_author: 15 s horizon shortened to 0.003 s in all controls.; Replace unavailable groovyBC with the current maintainer codedFixedValue parabolic/cosine inlet.; Direct solver unavailable because conda deal.II 9.3.2 lacks UMFPACK; CG is an explicit numerical adaptation.; Third attempt tightens fluid absolute tolerances to 1e-11.

Repeat the run#

These steps describe the recorded run. Environment reconstruction and any changes to author code are identified above. Downloadable drivers retain the original source references and input hashes.

  1. argv: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/env/bin/cmake; -S; /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/dealii-adapter; -B; /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/build-dealii-attempt2; -DCMAKE_PREFIX_PATH=/workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/env; -DCMAKE_CXX_COMPILER=/usr/bin/g++; cwd: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi; log: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/dealii-configure-attempt2.log
  2. argv: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/env/bin/cmake; --build; /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/build-dealii-attempt2; -j2; cwd: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi; log: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/dealii-build.log
  3. argv: ./Allwmake; cwd: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/openfoam-adapter; environment_wrapper: /home/builderbob/.local/bin/openfoam; environment_overrides: FOAM_USER_LIBBIN: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/lib; PKG_CONFIG_PATH: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/env/lib/pkgconfig; LD_LIBRARY_PATH: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/env/lib plus installed wrapper prefix; PATH: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/env/bin plus inherited path; GXX: /usr/bin/g++; WM_NCOMPPROCS: 2; MAKEFLAGS: LIB_SRC=/workspace/cache/builderbob/engineering-tools/20261029/solvers/include/OpenFOAM-2412/src GXX=/usr/bin/g++; log: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/openfoam-adapter/adapter-build-attempt2.log
  4. participant: solid; argv: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/build-dealii-attempt2/elasticity; parameters.prm; cwd: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/qualification-cg/solid-dealii
  5. participant: fluid; argv: /home/builderbob/.local/bin/openfoam; pimpleFoam; cwd: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/qualification-cg/fluid-openfoam

Comparison#

Observable: Settled-window x/y tip displacement mean/amplitude/frequency and combined force

Reference: Author ref_fsi3.point dt0.00025; SHA256c428bc3ff48c1698cd10aacf0941cba6aabdfcb9d61c8b7e42c343f381434e63

Rule and basis: Not established.. No valid benchmark pass threshold before resolving reference version, matching input and mesh/time-step convergence. Short coupling qualification cannot satisfy settled-oscillation target.

Defined before this run: True. Comparison scope: Try compatible preCICE2.5/deal.II9.3 stack with installed OpenCFD2412. A short run may qualify participant coupling while a full hours-scale benchmark remains pending.

Measured results:

{
  "qualification_windows": [
    {
      "attempt": "qualification-cg",
      "windows": [
        {
          "window": 1,
          "iterations": 100,
          "converged": false
        },
        {
          "window": 2,
          "iterations": 100,
          "converged": false
        },
        {
          "window": 3,
          "iterations": 30,
          "converged": true
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "attempt": "qualification-tight",
      "windows": [
        {
          "window": 1,
          "iterations": 100,
          "converged": false
        },
        {
          "window": 2,
          "iterations": 100,
          "converged": false
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "cg_final_tip": {
    "time_s": 0.003,
    "dx_m": -2.8799859e-08,
    "dy_m": -4.82644979e-09,
    "interpretation": "Transient diagnostic values; the first two preceding windows were unconverged."
  }
}

No published periodic observable compared. A short transient cannot recover FSI3 mean, amplitude or frequency; exit 0 did not establish coupling convergence.

Run result: Actual coupling executed. The CG adaptation completed 0.003 s with both participants exiting 0, but the first two of three windows were unconverged. A tighter fluid solver retry also failed its first two windows and hit the 240 s bound. The Direct solver failed due to missing UMFPACK. No qualified coupled solution or paper-result comparison.

Outputs and evidence#

  • run-record.json — Shared two-tool actual execution and failure provenance; SHA256 000ed88932d43215f0eb820a48888da3a968d3e3331b0a223c0181e6e9675c85.
  • precice-Solid-iterations.log — Native CG coupling convergence flags; SHA256 f3c5f5149425712c7cc5eb7fb9a13cd76c71b683bbbea2b726a3e0a1723c33b8.
  • precice-Solid-watchpoint-Flap-Tip.log — Transient diagnostic watchpoint; unconverged preceding windows; SHA256 cae3fd169db99133000bbaa9d47e2fd6c77dad5978ce72721568ff45abb05b4f.
  • precice-Solid-iterations.log — Native tighter-tolerance retry convergence flags; SHA256 9ace7d95a9d615ac9ef8329b29f7338f5028f99b93658901504793645a6e8314.

Complete run record. Native outputs, command logs and failed attempts are retained in the development evidence directory identified by that record.

Limits and next step#

Blockers: Installed deal.II 9.3.2 build has no UMFPACK; author Direct solver unavailable.; CG adaptation failed implicit coupling convergence in the first two windows; tighter fluid tolerances did not resolve it.; Current neo-Hookean solid, publication and reference-series constitutive alignment unresolved.; Full periodic benchmark and refinement study require a qualified setup and an hours-scale run; not launched.

Next action: Qualify the Direct solver or CG alternative and converged coupling; resolve original 2006 versus 2010 reference/material law; then predeclare the analysis window/tolerance and run the full horizon with mesh/time-step convergence.

View source on GitHub