preCICE
本页内容
耦合流体/结构求解能否恢复已发布的 FSI3 振荡和力可观测量?
执行: 尝试过;被阻止。 论文比较: 不成立。人类科学审查正在等待中。
论文和作者代码#
Proposal for Numerical Benchmarking of Fluid-Structure Interaction between an Elastic Object and Laminar Incompressible Flow (10.1007/3-540-34596-5_15). 出版物类型:书籍章节。
论文地点: 原始2006年FSI3基准;维护的教程还引用了 2010 年扩展 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-14206-2_8. 历史参考/本构对齐未解决;没有原始结果比较。
来源;参考:v202211.0;提交:0482e5b4d3e1604dd031d2b113a2aaa63733c9a8。
源文件: turek-hron-fsi3/precice-config.xml; turek-hron-fsi3/fluid-openfoam/run.sh; turek-hron-fsi3/solid-dealii/run.sh; turek-hron-fsi3/solid-dealii/parameters.prm
条款: preCICE教程LGPL-3.0;解算器和适配器许可证分别适用
与论文的关系: 文献基准的维护者实施;该工具提供分区耦合。 preCICE 和 deal.II 记录均指一项耦合实验。确切的历史案例等效性和科学目标仍未解决。
输入和环境#
描述:固定案例中的 FSI3 几何形状、流体/固体本构参数、入口坡道、网格、时间步长和 XML 耦合设置。访问:案例/网格公开。检索到作者 FSI3 参考系列(1,113,417 字节;SHA256c428bc3ff48c1698cd10aacf0941cba6aabdfcb9d61c8b7e42c343f381434e63);这是上游数据,不是本地 simulation。;哈希值:qualification-cg/precice-config.xml:924518a5fa58a2ee1eaec42a8eaedb527adeaf7b0ae5f700b5179abbe01b8c68;资格-cg/solid-dealii/parameters.prm:b5dd918bcb97daa1918f289066c914386a88acab589b10e0c05c823a50541a3d;资格-cg/fluid-openfoam/0/U:9c4083af85c05dc489a2a2fb06d9807c44a1beb82b198e8123d774f2fdd5a874;资格-cg/fluid-openfoam/system/fvSolution:a0d399eaba95fbe39a0d1cd3aeb2eb4a0a834312772354cc0c553e22d2752d75;资格严格/流体-openfoam/系统/fv解决方案:01990053fa8dd2adf52a30c86bbf20ec392c17d610b9ddc4c154f891f9564396
版本:boost-cpp:1.74.0; cmake:3.27.9;交易:9.3.2; openmpi:4.1.6; petsc:3.17.4;精度:2.5.0;开放泡沫:OpenCFD2412;编译器:GCC13.3.0; changes_from_author:所有控件中 15 秒的时间范围缩短为 0.003 秒。将不可用的 groovyBC 替换为当前维护者编码的FixedValue抛物线/余弦入口。;直接求解器不可用,因为 conda deal.II 9.3.2 缺少 UMFPACK; CG 是一种明确的数值改编。第三次尝试将流体绝对公差收紧至 1e-11。
重复运行#
这些步骤描述了记录的运行。环境重建和对作者代码的任何更改均已在上面标识。可下载的驱动程序保留原始源引用和输入哈希值。
argv: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/env/bin/cmake; -S; /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/dealii-adapter; -B; /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/build-dealii-attempt2; -DCMAKE_PREFIX_PATH=/workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/env; -DCMAKE_CXX_COMPILER=/usr/bin/g++; cwd: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi; log: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/dealii-configure-attempt2.logargv: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/env/bin/cmake; --build; /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/build-dealii-attempt2; -j2; cwd: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi; log: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/dealii-build.logargv: ./Allwmake; cwd: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/openfoam-adapter; environment_wrapper: /home/builderbob/.local/bin/openfoam; environment_overrides: FOAM_USER_LIBBIN: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/lib; PKG_CONFIG_PATH: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/env/lib/pkgconfig; LD_LIBRARY_PATH: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/env/lib plus installed wrapper prefix; PATH: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/env/bin plus inherited path; GXX: /usr/bin/g++; WM_NCOMPPROCS: 2; MAKEFLAGS: LIB_SRC=/workspace/cache/builderbob/engineering-tools/20261029/solvers/include/OpenFOAM-2412/src GXX=/usr/bin/g++; log: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/openfoam-adapter/adapter-build-attempt2.logparticipant: solid; argv: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/build-dealii-attempt2/elasticity; parameters.prm; cwd: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/qualification-cg/solid-dealiiparticipant: fluid; argv: /home/builderbob/.local/bin/openfoam; pimpleFoam; cwd: /workspace/repos/builderbob/open-source-research-initiative/planning/simulation-reproduction-2026-11-15/runs/numerics/fsi/qualification-cg/fluid-openfoam
比较#
可观察到: 固定窗口 x/y 尖端位移平均值/幅度/频率和组合力
参考: 作者ref_fsi3.point dt0.00025; SHA256c428bc3ff48c1698cd10aacf0941cba6aabdfcb9d61c8b7e42c343f381434e63
规则和依据: 未建立。在解析参考版本、匹配输入和网格/时间步收敛之前没有有效的基准测试通过阈值。短耦合鉴定无法满足固定振荡目标。
在此运行之前定义: 确实如此。 比较范围: 尝试使用已安装的 OpenCFD2412 兼容 preCICE2.5/deal.II9.3 堆栈。短期运行可能会使参与者耦合合格,而完整的小时规模基准仍有待确定。
测量结果:
{
"qualification_windows": [
{
"attempt": "qualification-cg",
"windows": [
{
"window": 1,
"iterations": 100,
"converged": false
},
{
"window": 2,
"iterations": 100,
"converged": false
},
{
"window": 3,
"iterations": 30,
"converged": true
}
]
},
{
"attempt": "qualification-tight",
"windows": [
{
"window": 1,
"iterations": 100,
"converged": false
},
{
"window": 2,
"iterations": 100,
"converged": false
}
]
}
],
"cg_final_tip": {
"time_s": 0.003,
"dx_m": -2.8799859e-08,
"dy_m": -4.82644979e-09,
"interpretation": "Transient diagnostic values; the first two preceding windows were unconverged."
}
}
没有公布的定期可观察数据进行比较。短暂瞬变无法恢复 FSI3 平均值、幅度或频率;出口0没有建立耦合收敛。
运行结果: 实际执行的耦合。 CG 适应完成了 0.003 秒,两个参与者都退出了 0,但三个窗口中的前两个未收敛。更严格的流体求解器重试也未能满足前两个窗口的要求,并达到了 240 秒的极限。由于缺少 UMFPACK,直接求解器失败。没有合格的耦合解决方案或论文结果比较。
结果和证据#
- run-record.json — 共享两种工具的实际执行和故障根源; SHA256
000ed88932d43215f0eb820a48888da3a968d3e3331b0a223c0181e6e9675c85. - precice-Solid-iterations.log — 原生 CG 耦合收敛标志; SHA256
f3c5f5149425712c7cc5eb7fb9a13cd76c71b683bbbea2b726a3e0a1723c33b8. - precice-Solid-watchpoint-Flap-Tip.log — 瞬态诊断观察点;未收敛的先前窗口; SHA256
cae3fd169db99133000bbaa9d47e2fd6c77dad5978ce72721568ff45abb05b4f. - precice-Solid-iterations.log — 本机更严格的容差重试收敛标志; SHA256
9ace7d95a9d615ac9ef8329b29f7338f5028f99b93658901504793645a6e8314.
完整的运行记录。本机输出、命令日志和失败的尝试都保留在该记录标识的开发证据目录中。
限制和下一步#
阻碍者: 安装的 deal.II 9.3.2 版本没有 UMFPACK;作者 直接求解器不可用。; CG自适应在前两个窗口中隐式耦合收敛失败;更严格的液体耐受性并没有解决这个问题。当前的新胡克实体、出版物和参考系列的本构对齐尚未解决。完整的定期基准测试和细化研究需要合格的设置和小时规模的运行;没有启动。
下一步行动: 验证直接求解器或 CG 替代方案和聚合耦合;解决原始 2006 年与 2010 年参考/材料法的问题;然后预先声明分析窗口/公差并通过网格/时间步收敛运行全范围。