보유된 연구 노트 및 제외 사항
이 페이지의 내용
검토 결과, 불확실성 및 제외된 리드는 연결된 캠페인 증거에 유지됩니다.
공중 보건 — 발견#
[
"Bulgaria policy explicitly covers AI-generated text, data analysis, and other research components with disclosure and author accountability.",
"Evidence Public Health permits generated writing with disclosure, but explicit research and analysis/code permission was not found; AI auditor must assess and exclude if unclear. Its copyright statements conflict.",
"Sage permits disclosed research assistance, generated text and code, but prohibits AI analysis of experiences and themes; AI auditor should preserve this restriction.",
"Excluded Future-Journal of Public Health, Policy and Digital Medicine: mandatory conference registration https://fupress.org/journal/JPHPDM/index.php/journal.",
"These are discovery candidates, not verified recommendations; independent geography, fee, AI and editorial audits remain necessary."
]
공중 보건 - 수수료#
[
"All baseline and discovery candidates audited. Prior evidence retained where accurate; policies can change. Author-dependent third-party permission and chosen repository costs are separate from journal fees."
]
공중 보건 — 지리#
[
"Regional remit alone does not establish author residence restrictions. Publisher countries are left empty when not independently established. Eurosurveillance evidence is historical; current author eligibility remains unclear.",
"WHO primary-research study-country author-affiliation condition is an actual rule; it does not apply to all authors or all research formats."
]
공중 보건 — AI 정책#
[
"Policies interpreted conservatively; an AI disclosure requirement by itself is not proof of permission for every workflow element.",
"Eurosurveillance official policy blocked; search mirror not treated as direct official evidence."
]
공중 보건 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all 17 baseline and discovery records against all three completed fee, geography and AI helper patches, including routes, restrictions, location evidence and compatibility. Independently read official PAHO author instructions via direct HTTPS after web tool 403; SciELO RESS policy; CDC PCD author, editorial and about pages; Bulgarian journal official ethics PDF; and OUP European Journal of Public Health metric page. Other helper evidence was evaluated from its recorded claims rather than independently refetched in every case.",
"Preserved all pre-existing dated and clearly labeled historical/undated metrics; official 2025 European Journal 5.2 JIF and 4.8 CiteScore confirmed, as was PCD 2025 JIF 5.6. No extra acceptance estimate invented. Citation measures do not predict manuscript acceptance.",
"AI analysis/code for RESS and Bulgarian journal reflects code-assisted work within expressly contemplated data analysis, not explicit named permission for arbitrary code generation; PAHO research-conduct language supports a similarly bounded interpretation. Human verification and the relevant disclosure requirements apply.",
"These are agent evidence reviews, not human scientific review. Fee waivers, optional OA, special supplements and scope constraints remain as recorded by the fee and geography auditors. No remote actions performed."
]
[
{
"id": "public-health-preventing-chronic-disease",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Authorship by experts worldwide does not explicitly affirm universal geographic eligibility; instructions also include editorial review for executive-order compliance.",
"resolution": "Changed author eligibility to not_stated and added the official research-content condition to scope notes."
},
{
"id": "public-health-pan-american-journal",
"severity": "low",
"issue": "Journal instructions list research conduct, data collection and interpretation but do not specifically name generated code.",
"resolution": "Retained conditional compatibility under the campaign interpretation of human-responsible code-assisted analysis, explicitly marking the inference and retaining disclosure requirements."
},
{
"id": "public-health-epidemiologia-servicos-saude",
"severity": "low",
"issue": "Official policy expressly discusses AI in data collection and analysis and writing assistance, but does not name generated code.",
"resolution": "Retained conditional compatibility as code-assisted data analysis, an interpretation, with methods and separate writing disclosure."
},
{
"id": "public-health-bulgarian-journal",
"severity": "low",
"issue": "Official policy contemplates AI text generation, data analysis and other research components; code is not separately named. No separate comprehensive page or membership cost evidence.",
"resolution": "Retained qualified conditional compatibility and needs_verification fee route; code-assisted analysis is an interpretation."
},
{
"id": "public-health-eurosurveillance",
"severity": "low",
"issue": "Current journal editorial policy was inaccessible to the AI auditor, and journal location evidence is historical.",
"resolution": "Retained unclear AI compatibility and venue location caveat; no inference of current AI permission."
},
{
"id": "public-health-scandinavian-journal",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Five printed pages are free, but charges apply above that threshold; Sage policy has a generation restriction.",
"resolution": "Retained explicit page limit and unclear AI classification, without claiming that long submissions are free or that drafting is permitted."
}
]
건강 시스템 — 발견#
[
"Journal of Health Systems and Policies requires a statement of AI use; specific coverage of research, code, and drafting remains for independent policy audit.",
"Taylor & Francis journal pages returned 403 to direct web open; scope and fee details are official indexed snippets, not fully retrieved journal pages. Publisher AI policy exists but journal applicability and all three workflow permissions need independent audit.",
"Samsun AI policy and exact publisher require independent verification; broad health management scope may be narrower in practice.",
"Rejected npj Health Systems and International Journal of Health Policy and Management: standard research routes charge APCs (https://www.nature.com/npjhealthsyst/for-authors-and-referees/about/open-access ; https://www.ijhpm.com/journal/authors.note.php)."
]
의료 시스템 - 수수료#
[
"Every baseline and completed discovery candidate audited; free routes are distinct from optional paid OA and reader subscriptions."
]
의료 시스템 — 지리#
[
"Publisher countries left empty when the specific publishing office or headquarters was not independently verified. Location and author eligibility are not inferred from research remit.",
"Official search-indexed excerpts were inspected; full page retrieval was not independently established for every source. Unknown is retained where evidence is incomplete."
]
의료 시스템 — AI 정책#
기준선과 검색 기록에 대한 감사입니다. 출판사 명세서는 저널별로 우선 적용됩니다. 침묵은 허락이 아니다. 검색 스니펫은 직접 웹 액세스가 차단된 에메랄드 정책을 식별했습니다. Springer 코드와 Elsevier 제도/코드는 보수적으로 검증되지 않았습니다.
건강 시스템 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all 18 helper candidates and all three preceding fee, geography and AI policy files. Independently read Springer and Taylor & Francis AI policies, the Sage journal fee policy, WHO and Springer official journal metric pages; PAHO policy was blocked in web fetch and prior direct-page evidence is retained, not independently reconfirmed. Other role claims were examined for contradictions but not every underlying source was independently fetched.",
"Added current WHO Bulletin official 2025 impact factor and retained nine previously recorded Springer/Emerald measures. Empty metrics mean none verified during this review, not no metric exists. No acceptance rate inferred.",
"Taylor & Francis explicitly bars AI first drafts of manuscript sections; its prohibited classifications remain. Disclosure alone and silence do not establish substantive permission; unresolved fees and author eligibility remain unresolved. No remote writes or venue contact."
]
[
{
"id": "health-systems-health-care-management-science",
"severity": "material",
"issue": "AI audit treated absence of explicit code permission as a barrier despite explicit basic analysis permission.",
"resolution": "Replace complete AI policy with compatible conditional permissions under updated semantic contract; retain human oversight and disclosure."
},
{
"id": "health-systems-journal-of-medical-systems",
"severity": "material",
"issue": "AI audit treated absence of explicit code permission as a barrier despite explicit basic analysis permission.",
"resolution": "Replace complete AI policy with compatible conditional permissions under updated semantic contract; retain human oversight and disclosure."
}
]
시스템 엔지니어링 — 발견#
[
"All four journal pages identify hybrid publishing and no subscription APC; submission, page and other compulsory fees remain unverified. The publisher has separate AI research and manuscript-preparation policies; applicable journal-specific instructions and compatibility need independent audit. Scope does not require the initial program to conduct physical experiments."
]
시스템 엔지니어링 — 수수료#
[
"Independently opened each journal-specific author guidance or publisher route page. Elsevier and Taylor & Francis author instructions returned 403; previous official supporting evidence is preserved. No selective waiver or institutional agreement is assumed."
]
시스템 엔지니어링 — 지리#
[
"Direct Elsevier and Taylor & Francis journal and author pages returned 403; location and author eligibility remain uncertain.",
"Society contact identifies the institutional base, not necessarily a centralized editorial office. Publisher locations remain unassigned unless the journal-specific publishing institution was established."
]
시스템 엔지니어링 - AI 정책#
[
"Publisher policies may change; journal-specific overrides remain material. Springer group guidance and journal instructions differ on disclosure of copyediting. Wiley detailed research guidance was blocked."
]
시스템 엔지니어링 - 측정항목 검토#
[
"Independently challenged all 17 candidates against accessible official fee, location and AI sources. Direct HTTPS retrieval was used for Springer, Elsevier, Wiley publisher, Taylor & Francis publisher, JSS, IJIEM and JEMC; SJM author instructions and INCOSE manual were read via web retrieval.",
"Wiley journal and some INCOSE and society pages, both ScienceDirect journals and T&F journal-specific instructions were inaccessible to independent retrieval; associated findings retain the limitations and prior-agent evidence rather than inventing a contrary result. Springer group guidance requires human oversight, Methods reporting for research use and an end-of-paper AI declaration; Elsevier policy separately addresses research code/analysis and drafting.",
"Four new Springer venues and SoSyM have added 2025 citation metrics. Previously sourced historical metrics retained; no acceptance rate is derived and no difficulty bands are added. This is agent evidence review, not human scientific review."
]
[
{
"id": "systems-engineering-systems-engineering",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal-specific Wiley fee instructions returned 403 on independent retrieval; retained needs_verification from prior inspection. Wiley ethics guidance permits manuscript development with disclosure but did not establish research and analysis; detailed guidance inaccessible. Author eligibility: international; venue countries: United States. AI determination: unclear.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and unclear AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-reliability-engineering-and-system-safety",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Elsevier journal-specific fee/author pages blocked; general subscription policy does not rule out title-specific charges. Publisher guidance explicitly allows supervised drafting, code and analysis with disclosure, though journal-specific exceptions remain inaccessible. Author eligibility: unclear; venue countries: not established. AI determination: compatible.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and compatible AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-safety-science",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Elsevier journal-specific fee/author pages blocked; general subscription policy does not rule out title-specific charges. Publisher guidance explicitly allows supervised drafting, code and analysis with disclosure, though journal-specific exceptions remain inaccessible. Author eligibility: unclear; venue countries: not established. AI determination: compatible.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and compatible AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-engineering-management-journal",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal fee and author instructions blocked; indexed no-APC evidence does not settle submission or length charges. Taylor & Francis explicitly prohibits AI-generated manuscript first drafts or sections, so the AI exclusion is supported. Author eligibility: unclear; venue countries: United States. AI determination: prohibited.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and prohibited AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-international-journal-of-production-research",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal fee and author instructions blocked; indexed no-APC evidence does not settle submission or length charges. Taylor & Francis explicitly prohibits AI-generated manuscript first drafts or sections, so the AI exclusion is supported. Author eligibility: unclear; venue countries: not established. AI determination: prohibited.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and prohibited AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-research-in-engineering-design",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal-specific Springer publishing and submission pages establish optional OA versus subscription and human accountability; no APC does not exclude submission or overlength charges. Springer group guidance allows supervised research assistance, exploratory analysis and drafting with Methods and declaration disclosures. Author eligibility: not_stated; venue countries: not established. AI determination: compatible.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and compatible AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-requirements-engineering",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal-specific Springer publishing and submission pages establish optional OA versus subscription and human accountability; no APC does not exclude submission or overlength charges. Springer group guidance allows supervised research assistance, exploratory analysis and drafting with Methods and declaration disclosures. Author eligibility: not_stated; venue countries: not established. AI determination: compatible.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and compatible AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-software-and-systems-modeling",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal-specific Springer publishing and submission pages establish optional OA versus subscription and human accountability; no APC does not exclude submission or overlength charges. Springer group guidance allows supervised research assistance, exploratory analysis and drafting with Methods and declaration disclosures. Author eligibility: not_stated; venue countries: not established. AI determination: compatible.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and compatible AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-systems-research-and-behavioral-science",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal-specific Wiley fee instructions returned 403 on independent retrieval; retained needs_verification from prior inspection. Wiley ethics guidance permits manuscript development with disclosure but did not establish research and analysis; detailed guidance inaccessible. Author eligibility: not_stated; venue countries: not established. AI determination: unclear.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and unclear AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-journal-of-system-safety",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Official author guidelines expressly exclude submission, APC and other author payments; free ORCID required. Journal-specific guidelines do not establish substantive AI permission; society location page was inaccessible on independent direct retrieval. Author eligibility: not_stated; venue countries: United States. AI determination: unclear.",
"resolution": "Preserve verified_free fee status and unclear AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-serbian-journal-of-management",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Official author instructions were readable through web retrieval: submission and publication are free and Serbia is named as publisher location; no substantive AI policy was established, so AI remains unclear. Author eligibility: not_stated; venue countries: Serbia. AI determination: unclear.",
"resolution": "Preserve verified_free fee status and unclear AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-journal-of-engineering-management-and-competitiveness",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Official journal policy excludes all author submission and publication charges, welcomes international authors and expressly forbids substantial AI-generated manuscript portions. AI research use requires detailed Methods disclosure. Author eligibility: international (corrected); venue countries: Serbia. AI determination: prohibited.",
"resolution": "Preserve verified_free fee status and prohibited AI status with conditions and source limitations; use corrected international author eligibility."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-international-journal-of-industrial-engineering-and-management",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Official author page excludes submission, review and publication charges, with third-party permissions potentially payable. Journal about page identifies Serbia; no full-workflow AI permission established. Author eligibility: not_stated; venue countries: Serbia. AI determination: unclear.",
"resolution": "Preserve verified_free fee status and unclear AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-international-journal-of-system-assurance-engineering-and-management",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal-specific Springer publishing and submission pages establish optional OA versus subscription and human accountability; no APC does not exclude submission or overlength charges. Springer group guidance allows supervised research assistance, exploratory analysis and drafting with Methods and declaration disclosures. Author eligibility: not_stated; venue countries: not established. AI determination: compatible.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and compatible AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-journal-of-systems-science-and-systems-engineering",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal-specific Springer publishing and submission pages establish optional OA versus subscription and human accountability; no APC does not exclude submission or overlength charges. Springer group guidance allows supervised research assistance, exploratory analysis and drafting with Methods and declaration disclosures. Author eligibility: not_stated; venue countries: not established. AI determination: compatible.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and compatible AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-engineering-with-computers",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal-specific Springer publishing and submission pages establish optional OA versus subscription and human accountability; no APC does not exclude submission or overlength charges. Springer group guidance allows supervised research assistance, exploratory analysis and drafting with Methods and declaration disclosures. Author eligibility: not_stated; venue countries: not established. AI determination: compatible.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and compatible AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
},
{
"id": "systems-engineering-journal-of-intelligent-manufacturing",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal-specific Springer publishing and submission pages establish optional OA versus subscription and human accountability; no APC does not exclude submission or overlength charges. Springer group guidance allows supervised research assistance, exploratory analysis and drafting with Methods and declaration disclosures. Author eligibility: not_stated; venue countries: not established. AI determination: compatible.",
"resolution": "Preserve needs_verification fee status and compatible AI status with conditions and source limitations; do not infer author eligibility from journal location or lack of stated restrictions."
}
]
작업-simulation — 검색#
[
"Four additional journal leads outside the field baseline. The journal-specific Discrete Event Dynamic Systems instructions explicitly exclude submission and publication costs; the other three subscription routes remain needs_verification for submission, page, and membership costs. No conference registration is involved.",
"Springer Nature AI guidance https://group.springernature.com/gp/group/ai/ai-guidance-for-researchers-editors-reviewers describes disclosed research and manuscript preparation assistance, but restricts writing entire manuscripts and interpretation; applicability and all three workflow permissions require independent AI-policy review.",
"Subscription is a reader-access model; no APC alone does not establish all author costs. Optional OA and institutional agreements are not counted as unconditional free access. Agent discovery is not human scientific review."
]
작업-simulation — 수수료#
[
"All baseline and completed discovery candidates examined. The Springer and INFORMS hybrid titles without express fee coverage remain unverified. Optional print color and open access are not mandatory costs. ORiON later timed out and RAIRO journal instructions were blocked; historical evidence retained with those limits."
]
Operations-simulation — 지리#
[
"Journal office locations remain unknown where only a multinational publisher or geographically distributed editorial board was identified. Author eligibility is not inferred from an international journal title or scope. RAIRO journal site was unavailable."
]
Operations-simulation — AI 정책#
[
"All 19 journal author instruction pages were opened; RAIRO returned HTTP 403 and SORT opened but a follow-up text search timed out. No qualifying policy was established for the five independent journals. Sage explicitly prohibits AI analysis of experiences and themes while allowing AI-generated research code."
]
작업-simulation — 측정항목 검토#
[
"All 19 baseline and discovery records and all three role patches reviewed. Publisher AI policies and selected fee, geographic and metrics evidence independently checked; findings retain per-candidate uncertainties. Historical source-backed metrics are preserved without difficulty labels.",
"RAIRO journal instructions blocked (HTTP 403); SORT author instructions timed out and Sage defense journal instructions were inaccessible on independent recheck. Access limitations are not evidence of prohibition. Acceptance rates with unknown period or denominator remain labeled accordingly.",
"Springer Nature publisher guidance requires version, dates, prompts and contribution extent, in addition to placement of declarations; corrections preserve the full AI policy fields.",
"Independently attempted official fee, location and AI source retrieval for every candidate, read shared publisher policies and journal instructions where accessible. Direct fetching of INFORMS and Sage was blocked but web retrieval recovered the INFORMS instructions, SIMULATION and Simulation & Gaming; defense journal instructions remained inaccessible. Springer direct responses were challenge pages, while web retrieval recovered journal pages. SORT author instructions timed out; RAIRO returned 403. ORiON submissions instructions opened on recheck. No access failure establishes a ban."
]
[
{
"id": "operations-simulation-stochastic-systems",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee status verified_free: The current journal instructions explicitly exclude APCs and submission fees. Regular manuscripts are limited to 35 pages including references; short correspondences to eight pages. No author membership, registration payment or institutional agreement is required by the stated route. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: United States. AI status compatible: INFORMS permits generative AI in manuscript preparation and expressly describes data analysis, summarization and text drafting. Human authors remain responsible for accuracy, integrity and originality. Explicit permission for analysis covers analytical assistance under this contract.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-mathematics-of-operations-research",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status needs_verification: Standard subscription publication exists alongside optional paid INFORMS Open Option. The reviewed pages do not explicitly exclude submission, page or membership charges. Normally at most 40 manuscript pages excluding references; up to 45 may be considered with justification. Print color is optional and charged. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: United States. AI status compatible: INFORMS permits generative AI in manuscript preparation and expressly describes data analysis, summarization and text drafting. Human authors remain responsible for accuracy, integrity and originality. Explicit permission for analysis covers analytical assistance under this contract.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-operations-research",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status needs_verification: Optional paid OA is documented, but no explicit no-fee standard-route statement was found. Regular manuscripts are limited to 30 pages excluding references; longer manuscripts are generally at most 40. Print color incurs a cost only if elected. Journal fees must not be inferred from other INFORMS journals. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: United States. AI status compatible: INFORMS permits generative AI in manuscript preparation and expressly describes data analysis, summarization and text drafting. Human authors remain responsible for accuracy, integrity and originality. Explicit permission for analysis covers analytical assistance under this contract.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-informs-journal-on-computing",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status needs_verification: Ordinary subscription publication remains available beside optional paid INFORMS Open Option. Main papers may contain 25 pages including references, tables and graphs, plus up to ten appendix pages; editorial permission is needed for exceptions. Print color is elective and charged. Explicit confirmation of submission, standard publication and page/member costs remains absent. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: United States. AI status compatible: INFORMS permits generative AI in manuscript preparation and expressly describes data analysis, summarization and text drafting. Human authors remain responsible for accuracy, integrity and originality. Explicit permission for analysis covers analytical assistance under this contract.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-queueing-systems",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status needs_verification: The journal identifies itself as hybrid; Springer Nature explicitly excludes APCs when authors select subscription publication. Online color is free; requested print color, offprints and elective OA can cost money. No explicit submission, page/overlength or compulsory membership assurance was located. Subscription licensing may not meet an immediate-OA funder mandate. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: not established. AI status compatible: Springer Nature permits AI support for research, basic statistical analysis and drafting literature reviews or summaries with human validation. This supports analytical assistance and substantive drafting, not autonomous authorship.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-annals-of-operations-research",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status needs_verification: The journal identifies itself as hybrid; Springer Nature explicitly excludes APCs when authors select subscription publication. Online color is free; requested print color, offprints and elective OA can cost money. No explicit submission, page/overlength or compulsory membership assurance was located. Subscription licensing may not meet an immediate-OA funder mandate. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: not established. AI status compatible: Springer Nature permits AI support for research, basic statistical analysis and drafting literature reviews or summaries with human validation. This supports analytical assistance and substantive drafting, not autonomous authorship.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-or-spectrum",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status needs_verification: The journal identifies itself as hybrid; Springer Nature explicitly excludes APCs when authors select subscription publication. Online color is free; requested print color, offprints and elective OA can cost money. No explicit submission, page/overlength or compulsory membership assurance was located. Subscription licensing may not meet an immediate-OA funder mandate. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: not established. AI status compatible: Springer Nature permits AI support for research, basic statistical analysis and drafting literature reviews or summaries with human validation. This supports analytical assistance and substantive drafting, not autonomous authorship.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-simulation",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee status verified_free: The journal explicitly excludes fees to submit or publish. Choose standard subscription publication; Sage Choice OA and requested print color are optional paid choices, while online color is free. No fixed manuscript-length cap or mandatory page, society-membership or registration payment is specified in the instructions checked. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: United States. AI status compatible: Sage permits disclosed AI literature support and generated or checked code for further research, and describes disclosed generation of text. Authors must verify outputs and remain responsible. Analytical coding satisfies this workflow, subject to explicit qualitative-analysis restrictions. Correction: journal instructions expressly encourage authors from all countries; replace the not_stated geographic status with international.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-simulation-and-gaming",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee status verified_free: The journal explicitly excludes fees to submit or publish. Standard subscription publication is free; paid OA and print color are optional, and online color is free. Limits excluding references: research articles 7000 words, short research reports 3000, theoretical and ready-to-use simulations 5000. Longer articles need explicit editorial permission. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: not established. AI status compatible: Sage permits disclosed AI literature support and generated or checked code for further research, and describes disclosed generation of text. Authors must verify outputs and remain responsible. Analytical coding satisfies this workflow, subject to explicit qualitative-analysis restrictions.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-journal-of-defense-modeling-and-simulation",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee status verified_free: Current journal instructions explicitly exclude submission/publication fees; paid OA is optional and online color is free. Avoid requested print color. Papers are ideally 10-20 pages although the stated submission policy imposes no fixed length restriction. No compulsory membership is stated. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: United States. AI status compatible: Sage permits disclosed AI literature support and generated or checked code for further research, and describes disclosed generation of text. Authors must verify outputs and remain responsible. Analytical coding satisfies this workflow, subject to explicit qualitative-analysis restrictions. Independent author-instructions retrieval was blocked by direct HTTP 403 and web fetch failure; the journal-specific role evidence could not be independently re-read.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-croatian-operational-research-review",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status verified_free: Ordinary journal submission, without conference attendance. Manuscripts should contain 10–12 pages including bibliography, with at most 30 references. Final accepted files must use LaTeX. Authors must supply proofreading confirmation; the instructions make proofreading their responsibility and do not require a paid provider. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: Croatia. AI status unclear: Official journal author instructions were inspected; a policy expressly allowing all three requested uses was not established. Silence is not permission.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-sort-statistics-and-operations-research-transactions",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status verified_free: English-language original articles; an online RACO account is required without a stated payment. Normally at most about 25 PDF pages, or 40 pages using the SORT LaTeX template, including figures, tables and references; justified longer articles are possible. LaTeX is recommended initially and required at revision. The general no-fee statement is not a selective waiver. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: Spain. AI status unclear: Official journal author instructions were inspected; a policy expressly allowing all three requested uses was not established. Silence is not permission. Journal author-instructions source timed out on independent retrieval; other stated evidence and historical metrics remain bounded.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-operations-research-and-decisions",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status verified_free: Current author instructions explicitly exclude both APCs and submission charges; the homepage also excludes publication fees and the aims page describes an institution-funded free journal. No selective waiver or affiliation agreement is required. Non-survey manuscripts may have at most 35 references. Revised manuscripts must use the journal LaTeX template and EPS figures; converted Word source or converted raster figures are not accepted. No compulsory membership, registration payment or page tariff is stated. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: Poland. AI status unclear: Official journal author instructions were inspected; a policy expressly allowing all three requested uses was not established. Silence is not permission.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-orion",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status needs_verification: Official policy explicitly excludes APCs and page fees under a Submission Fees heading; separate submission-fee wording remains unresolved. The submission checklist and guidelines state no membership or conference-registration payment and no manuscript page cap. Research articles have a distinct peer-review route; special issues require invitation. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: South Africa. AI status unclear: Official journal author instructions were inspected; a policy expressly allowing all three requested uses was not established. Silence is not permission. Journal submissions instructions were independently accessible on recheck; they state no explicit fee or qualifying AI permission, so fee verification and AI compatibility remain uncertain.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-rairo-operations-research",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status verified_free: Publisher-supported Subscribe to Open route confirmed for 2026 content. The publisher excludes submission fees and provides free publication for the mathematics S2O journals, including authors at institutions without an S2O subscription. No selective waiver is needed. Open-access status is decided annually; recheck the eventual publication year. Journal-specific length/production instructions remain unreadable because of HTTP 403. Author eligibility is unclear; venue country evidence: not established. AI status unclear: A qualifying AI policy was not verified in the available author guidance and targeted searches; the requested permissions remain uncertain. Journal-specific instructions returned 403; future-year S2O conditions and restrictions remain uncertain.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-computational-optimization-and-applications",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status needs_verification: Subscription route has no APC; optional open access has an APC. Submission, compulsory page and membership costs remain unverified. Online color is free; confirm any print-color costs. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: not established. AI status compatible: Springer Nature permits AI support for research, basic statistical analysis and drafting literature reviews or summaries with human validation. This supports analytical assistance and substantive drafting, not autonomous authorship. Added both official 2025 impact factors; they do not estimate acceptance.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-discrete-event-dynamic-systems",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee status verified_free: Instructions explicitly state no submission or publication fee and no author cost on standard publication. Short papers are limited to 12 journal pages; optional OA has an APC. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: not established. AI status compatible: Springer Nature permits AI support for research, basic statistical analysis and drafting literature reviews or summaries with human validation. This supports analytical assistance and substantive drafting, not autonomous authorship. Added both official 2025 impact factors; they do not estimate acceptance.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-journal-of-scheduling",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status needs_verification: Subscription route has no APC; optional open access has an APC. Submission, compulsory page and membership costs remain unverified. Online color is free; confirm any print-color costs. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: not established. AI status compatible: Springer Nature permits AI support for research, basic statistical analysis and drafting literature reviews or summaries with human validation. This supports analytical assistance and substantive drafting, not autonomous authorship. Added both official 2025 impact factors; they do not estimate acceptance.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
},
{
"id": "operations-simulation-journal-of-combinatorial-optimization",
"severity": "caution",
"issue": "Fee status needs_verification: Subscription route has no APC; optional open access has an APC. Submission, compulsory page and membership costs remain unverified. Online color is free; confirm any print-color costs. Author eligibility is not_stated; venue country evidence: not established. AI status compatible: Springer Nature permits AI support for research, basic statistical analysis and drafting literature reviews or summaries with human validation. This supports analytical assistance and substantive drafting, not autonomous authorship. Added both official 2025 impact factors; they do not estimate acceptance.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and author-geography statuses and the policy limitations; consult linked journal and publisher evidence before submission."
}
]
정보학-컴퓨팅 — 발견#
[
"AI compatibility is not established by discovery: separately audit all uses and disclosure. IRRJ requires full disclosure of generative AI used in research and writing; whether it explicitly permits analysis/code remains for the AI auditor.",
"JFP moved from Cambridge to the JFP Charity and Episciences in 2026; old Cambridge APC policy is historical, not the current route.",
"IRRJ conference abstracts are not the journal route; conference registration is not established. No ACM or IEEE conference candidates were selected."
]
정보학 컴퓨팅 — 수수료#
[
"All listed baseline and campaign discovery records audited. Source evidence is dated per entry. The Episciences model excludes publication charges but its statement about per-unit publication fees does not independently rule out a distinct submission fee. Event and conference routes are outside the ordinary journal routes."
]
정보학-컴퓨팅 — 지리#
[
"Author geographic eligibility is not inferred from international scope, editors, society names, or silence. Unknown journal bases remain empty.",
"JOSS fiscal-host address does not imply an editorial office. JFP ownership changed in 2026; arXiv separated from Cornell in July 2026."
]
정보학-컴퓨팅 — AI 정책#
캠페인 도우미의 모든 기준과 검색 후보가 검사되었습니다. 검색 스니펫은 신뢰할 수 있는 정책으로 처리되지 않았습니다. 공개 전용 문구 자체로는 허가가 설정되지 않습니다. TheoretiCS 현재 페이지가 색인이 생성된 이전 스니펫과 다릅니다. 라이브 페이지를 사용합니다.
정보학-컴퓨팅 — 측정항목-검토#
[
"Inspected all 20 baseline plus discovery records and the fee, geography, and AI role patches. Independently read the official JOSS, JGAA and TheoretiCS AI policies, JAIR fee FAQ, JSS submission guide, JMLR news and TheoretiCS statistics. Other venue claims were inspected from the other role files and not independently reverified; no claim of complete independent source coverage.",
"Added official historical JMLR 2004 impact factor; existing reported metrics retained with date and population. Citation impact is not acceptance probability. No subjective difficulty judgments.",
"Agent evidence review only; no human editorial or scientific review."
]
[
{
"id": "informatics-computing-jgaa",
"severity": "material",
"issue": "Broad generative AI assistance permits programming and polishing, but the author page explicitly names editing of human-written prose and does not explicitly establish substantive drafting. The compatible classification overstates this evidence.",
"resolution": "Set compatibility unclear and manuscript drafting not_stated; retain mandatory disclosure and responsibilities."
},
{
"id": "informatics-computing-theoretics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Submission-year and acceptance-year counts have different populations, and 2025 cohort was incomplete at the April 2026 snapshot.",
"resolution": "Preserved dated figures and cohort caveats; no derived acceptance rate."
}
]
계산 생물학 - 발견#
[
"Four additional candidates, none in the baseline memberships. Fee and AI compatibility require independent review; do not infer free submission or affirmative full workflow permission.",
"Rejected Biology Methods & Protocols: fully open access with applicable article charges, https://academic.oup.com/biomethods/pages/general_instructions.",
"Elsevier 2026 policy https://www.elsevier.com/en-au/about/policies-and-standards/generative-ai-policies-for-journals discusses manuscript assistance and research methods disclosure, but https://researcheracademy.elsevier.com/uploads/2026-06/genai_factsheet_authors_v1_updated-1.pdf restricts substantive writing without author intellectual contribution; inspect journal-specific rules and founder workflow."
]
계산 생물학 - 수수료#
[
"All 19 baseline and discovery candidates independently checked against official pages. Author costs remain needs_verification where submission or compulsory additional charges are not established; paid open access and selective fee support are not universal zero-cost routes."
]
계산 생물학 - 지리학#
[
"All current baseline and discovery candidates assessed. Publisher country is omitted where no specific headquarters or publisher office was independently established. International eligibility is not inferred from subject scope or editorial diversity. ScienceDirect pages were blocked."
]
계산 생물학 — AI 정책#
[
"All baseline and discovery candidates inspected. Springer journal copyediting exemption conflicts with newer publisher guidance; both retained. Elsevier title-specific guides blocked."
]
계산 생물학 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Independently inspected official candidate homepages and fetched primary fee, geography and AI evidence links; direct access to Oxford pages and three ScienceDirect journal guides was blocked, while Oxford journal pages and applicable journal guidance were independently read using the web tool. Publisher pages and role evidence document any remaining blocked sources.",
"The eight Springer publisher homepages were independently retrieved; earlier official metrics are preserved as sourced rather than discarded. PLOS journal editorial provides historical approximate article-type acceptance, not a current all-journal figure. No difficulty bands were added.",
"Agent evidence review is not human scientific review. Author location and research location remain separate; no inferred international eligibility."
]
[
{
"id": "computational-biology-journal-of-mathematical-biology",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Subscription APC-free route does not prove free submission or all mandatory charges; journal base and author geography remain unstated; publisher AI permits limited human-led drafting and analysis.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-bulletin-of-mathematical-biology",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Society association does not automatically establish worldwide author eligibility; retain unverified submission costs and human-led AI conditions.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-theory-in-biosciences",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Subscription publication has no APC; submission and other mandatory charges remain unverified, and geographic eligibility is not stated.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-interdisciplinary-sciences-computational-life-sciences",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Journal is hybrid with optional paid OA; no general zero-submission proof; distinguish journal base from publisher location and retain AI research disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-network-modeling-analysis-health-informatics-bioinformatics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "No APC under subscription is not proof of zero submission fee; no established author-location permission; publisher AI use requires human judgment.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-acta-biotheoretica",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Undisclosed author locations are not evidence of international eligibility; free subscription APC does not settle other author charges.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-journal-of-biological-physics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Subscription route excludes APC but not unverified other charges; research geography and author eligibility must not be conflated.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-journal-of-molecular-modeling",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Optional colour and OA do not establish no submission fee; geographic location and author eligibility require separate evidence.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-plos-computational-biology",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee assistance is conditional; PLOS guidance permits disclosed generated content and analysis, subject to author accountability; no blanket author location guarantee.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-bioinformatics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fully OA with charges and conditional financial support; journal-specific prompt-drafting restriction overrides generic OUP guidance; geographic eligibility not affirmatively stated.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-biomath",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "No-charge route is explicitly supported; lack of an identified AI policy does not establish permission; the reported acceptance figures have differing periods and unknown denominators.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-biometrical-letters",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Journal states no author charges; broad AI disclosure language does not clearly establish substantive analysis and drafting permissions; author geography is unstated.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-biodiversity-informatics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Publishing fees excluded in journal author information; declaration examples include analysis, code and text, but a disclosure rule alone does not establish permission; author geography is unstated.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-peer-community-journal",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Free route requires successful prior PCI recommendation, not guaranteed acceptance; AI policy supports disclosed bibliography, analysis, text and code with human checks; no international author eligibility inferred.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-journal-of-open-source-software",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "No fees and software-development eligibility gates apply; journal permits disclosed AI in software and paper drafting under human validation; author geography is unstated.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-mathematical-biosciences",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Elsevier hybrid subscription policy does not confirm every title-specific fee; ScienceDirect guide blocked; publisher research support does not clearly authorize substantive initial draft generation.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-journal-of-theoretical-biology",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "ScienceDirect author guide blocked, so title-specific author fees and AI restrictions remain uncertain; publisher hybrid guidance alone does not establish zero total cost.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-biosystems",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "ScienceDirect author guide blocked; retain uncertainty about submission fees, journal geography and specific drafting restrictions.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
},
{
"id": "computational-biology-mathematical-medicine-and-biology",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Standard licence does not prove all fees; OUP policy discusses analysis and rewriting, but affirmative initial drafting permission remains unestablished; author location not stated.",
"resolution": "Retain the audited classification and evidence limitations; metrics are citation or historical context, not a prediction of acceptance."
}
]
계산-물리-과학 — 발견#
[
"Four additional venues support theoretical, simulation, or existing-data studies; no new physical laboratory work is assumed.",
"IOP author generative AI policy explicitly permits research, code and text generation with human validation and disclosure; AI policy role must independently verify journal applicability and restrictions: https://publishingsupport.iopscience.iop.org/questions/generative-ai-tools/",
"Materials Futures sponsors APCs currently; submission and ancillary-cost applicability requires independent audit.",
"Rejected Journal of Physics: Materials and Journal of Physics: Complexity: both disclose mandatory article publication charges absent a conditional agreement or waiver: https://publishingsupport.iopscience.iop.org/journals/journal-of-physics-materials/about-journal-physics-materials/ and https://publishingsupport.iopscience.iop.org/journals/journal-of-physics-complexity/about-journal-physics-complexity/"
]
계산-물리-과학 — 수수료#
[
"Complete route replacements for baseline and discovery candidates; current official journal pages and guidance were checked independently. Previous evidence preserved, including search snippets and blocked pages. Optional third-party rights, copyediting or print services are not assumed mandatory.",
"RSC, Physical Review E, Journal of Computational Physics and Condensed Matter Physics retain unresolved charges or inaccessible conditions."
]
계산-물리-과학 — 지리#
공식 저널, 호스트, 출판사 출처를 검토했습니다. 출판사 본사만으로는 장소 위치를 할당하는 데 사용되지 않습니다. PCCP에는 추가 국제 사회 공동 소유자가 있습니다. 나열된 영국 기반은 완전하지 않습니다. 일부 저널 호스트 페이지에 접근할 수 없거나 증거가 불충분합니다. 자격은 보수적으로 명시되지 않습니다.
계산-물리-과학 — AI 정책#
[
"Compatibility requires affirmative evidence across all requested uses; policy scope and blocked journal-specific instructions remain uncertainty."
]
계산-물리-과학 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all 19 merged records and all fee, geography and AI patches. Existing sourced metrics retained; five records have no reported metric. Independently checked current official APS journal metrics and APS and IOP AI policies: https://journals.aps.org/metrics, https://journals.aps.org/authors/appropriate-use-ai-tools, https://publishingsupport.iopscience.iop.org/questions/generative-ai-tools/. APS PRE 2025 JIF 2.5 and CiteScore 4.1 match existing values; IOP permits research, code and generated manuscript text with author validation and disclosure.",
"This is an agent evidence review, not independent human review. Source pages and earlier auditors evidence were reviewed selectively; no new external confirmation for every individual journal or all historical numbers. Fee and geography findings retain uncertainty; no absence of restrictions is treated as worldwide eligibility."
]
[
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-modelling-and-simulation-in-materials-science-and-engineering",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI compatible; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 1 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-journal-of-physics-a-mathematical-and-theoretical",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI compatible; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 1 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-journal-of-physics-condensed-matter",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI compatible; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 1 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-classical-and-quantum-gravity",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI compatible; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 1 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-physical-chemistry-chemical-physics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI unclear; fee route needs_verification; author geography not_stated; 1 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-soft-matter",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI unclear; fee route needs_verification; author geography not_stated; 1 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-journal-of-computational-physics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI unclear; fee route needs_verification; author geography not_stated; 0 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-physical-review-e",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI compatible; fee route needs_verification; author geography not_stated; 4 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-acta-crystallographica-section-a",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI unclear; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 5 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-acta-crystallographica-section-b",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI unclear; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 5 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-beilstein-journal-of-nanotechnology",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI unclear; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 3 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-beilstein-journal-of-organic-chemistry",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI unclear; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 3 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-turkish-journal-of-physics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI limited; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 1 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-turkish-journal-of-chemistry",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI limited; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 1 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-condensed-matter-physics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI unclear; fee route needs_verification; author geography international; 1 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-journal-of-physics-b-atomic-molecular-and-optical-physics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI compatible; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 0 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-journal-of-physics-d-applied-physics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI compatible; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 0 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-journal-of-micromechanics-and-microengineering",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI compatible; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 0 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
},
{
"id": "computational-physical-sciences-materials-futures",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Reviewed merged candidate: AI compatible; fee route verified_free; author geography not_stated; 0 existing metric(s).",
"resolution": "Retain current role evidence and historical metrics; exclusions and route conditions apply. No unsupported acceptance probability or author-location inference."
}
]
경제학 - 발견#
[
"Five global-baseline-new candidates. AI evidence is provisional; do not infer full workflow permission from disclosure or silence. Independent AI and fee review required.",
"Rejected European Journal of Economics and Economic Policies: its policy prohibits generative AI substantive analysis and development of written arguments despite no author fees: https://doi.org/10.4337/ejeep",
"Rejected Journal of Economics and Development: Emerald prohibits AI copywriting: https://www.emeraldgrouppublishing.com/journal/jed and https://www.emeraldgrouppublishing.com/publish-with-us/ethics-integrity/research-publishing-ethics",
"Rejected Economics: journal states a €1050 article processing charge: https://www.degruyterbrill.com/journal/key/econ/html"
]
경제 - 수수료#
[
"All baseline and discovery IDs audited. Current official stage-specific evidence is required; open reader access does not establish author cost. Closed and staged-2027 venue availability is separate from fee policy. Existing source observations preserved where independently retrieved; blocked current access is identified."
]
경제학 - 지리학#
게시자 위치가 독립적으로 확인되지 않았으며 비어 있습니다. 광범위한 제목, 저널 범위 및 국제적인 독자층은 전 세계 저자 자격의 증거로 간주되지 않습니다.
경제학 - AI 정책#
[
"Policy applicability is journal-specific; no inference from unrelated similar journal titles. Review of unverified or silent author guidance does not establish that no policy exists. Economics and Business Letters submission page currently states it is not accepting submissions."
]
경제학 — 지표 검토#
[
"Reviewed all 19 merged helper records and their fee, geography and AI-policy patch fields for internal consistency; independent official-source retrieval was targeted, not a fresh verification of every source. Official Swiss Society, Oxford guidance, Contextus and Afyon policy, EKOIST 2025 statistics, Economics and Business Letters metrics, and Comparative Economic Studies metrics were read. Other role observations are retained with their evidence and access limitations.",
"Existing sourced metrics retained, including official 2025 Comparative Economic Studies JIF 1.9 and five-year JIF 1.7, and EKOIST 2025 acceptance ratio 51% (36 accepted, 35 rejected; denominator/cohort limits noted). Economics and Business Letters 2025 JIF 1.0 and CiteScore 1.5 were confirmed. Citation metrics do not measure acceptance odds; no historical padding or inferred acceptance rate was added.",
"No independent live recheck of every fee, geographic claim or policy was possible in this review; unresolved or blocked policies remain uncertain. No remote actions."
]
[
{
"id": "economics-swiss-journal-of-economics-and-statistics",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Geography marked author eligibility unclear despite an affirmative worldwide submission statement by its owning society.",
"resolution": "Corrected complete geography field to international, citing the society."
},
{
"id": "economics-journal-of-comparative-economics",
"severity": "high",
"issue": "Oxford author guidance describes AI disclosure examples but does not expressly grant substantive permission; the 2027 Oxford portal is staged, and the current Elsevier policy was not independently confirmed.",
"resolution": "Classified AI compatibility unclear and retained staged/current route fee uncertainty; do not infer open submissions from the staged portal."
},
{
"id": "economics-central-european-economic-journal",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Disclosure examples for analysis, coding, and drafting alone were treated as conditional permissions.",
"resolution": "Retained unclear compatibility and required declaration while marking permissions not stated pending affirmative applicable evidence."
},
{
"id": "economics-economics-and-business-letters",
"severity": "high",
"issue": "The venue is closed to new submissions despite verified free fees; metrics do not make it available.",
"resolution": "Retain closure status and fee conditions; exclude from currently available main listings."
},
{
"id": "economics-contextus",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Official journal policy addresses substantive analysis, literature review, text generation and modeling, with disclosure and human responsibility.",
"resolution": "Compatible classification retained; analysis qualifies semantically without the literal word code. Fee eligibility remains needs_verification."
}
]
심리학 행동 - 발견#
[
"Springer journal guidelines for Computational Brain & Behavior and Current Psychology require disclosure of LLM use, but explicit permission for each substantive use remains for AI-policy audit; Psychonomic Bulletin & Review policy needs independent examination. Do not infer compatibility from silence.",
"Rejected Journal of Social and Political Psychology: https://jspp.psychopen.eu/index.php/jspp/policies expressly disallows AI-written original text. Rejected Spanish Journal of Psychology and Language and Cognition: their current fee pages describe fully open-access APC routes; the older Language and Cognition special-issue non-OA statement is obsolete."
]
심리학 행동 - 수수료#
모든 기준 및 검색 기록을 감사했습니다. Springer 구독 경로는 완전한 작성자 비용을 설정하지 않습니다. PsychOpen 용어는 전환 시 변경될 수 있습니다. 판단 및 의사결정을 위한 저널 수수료 페이지 시간이 초과되었습니다. 인용된 2024년 사설에서는 조건부 지원을 설명합니다. 독립적으로 조사되는 정책에서는 메타심리학 제출 비용이 명시적으로 제외되지 않습니다.
심리학 행동 - 지리학#
국제 포럼 또는 유럽 소관은 연구 범위이지 저자 자격 증명이 아닙니다. 출판사 위치와 확인되지 않은 저널 기반은 의도적으로 생략되었습니다. PsychOpen 플랫폼 이전은 현재 호스팅에 영향을 미칠 수 있습니다.
심리학 행동 - AI 정책#
[
"Sage prohibits GenAI analysis of experiences and themes; its conditional compatibility applies to other permitted research/code workflows. Springer compatibility requires human-led reasoning and disclosure. Four journals lack sufficient applicable evidence in inspected pages; Social Psychological Bulletin expressly prohibits original AI text."
]
심리학 행동 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all 18 candidate records and the fee, geography and AI policy patches. Independent official source checks included Sage journal instructions, Springer journal homepages and AI guidance, and PsychOpen policies; a role review is not human scientific review.",
"Prior metrics are retained with their original source, date and population rather than replaced with empty arrays. No inferred acceptance rates or subjective difficulty bands.",
"Springer exploratory analysis and author-led drafting guidance supports conditional compatibility under the campaign semantic rule; some article or use restrictions remain. Sage policy prohibits GenAI analysis of experiences or themes, limiting appropriate applications.",
"Sage journal instructions affirm worldwide authorship, and Current Psychology explicitly encourages authors worldwide; this does not eliminate other author or manuscript requirements.",
"Publisher journal homepages show no impact factor for Computational Brain & Behavior at the time checked; no missing metric is inferred."
]
[
{
"id": "psychology-behavior-psychological-research",
"severity": "note",
"issue": "The 2026 journal editorial describes a planned journal-specific requirement for examples of substantive AI use; the current publisher policy and the editorial differ on copy-editing disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain the applicable publisher disclosure and advise checking the current journal instructions for any newly implemented journal-specific requirement; editorial describes this as planned, not established. Source: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00426-026-02246-0."
},
{
"id": "psychology-behavior-social-psychological-bulletin",
"severity": "note",
"issue": "The journal prohibits AI-written original text even though it permits disclosed analytical assistance.",
"resolution": "Retain the prohibited manuscript drafting classification and exclude from the compatible main directory. https://spb.psychopen.eu/index.php/spb/policies"
}
]
사회학-organizations — 발견#
[
"Journal-specific AI instructions describe human accountability and disclosure of generated text and data analysis; independent AI audit must assess analysis-code coverage.",
"Rejected Business and Politics and Journal of Management & Organization: current publisher fees pages identify wholly Gold OA publication with APCs; https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/business-and-politics/information/author-instructions/fees-and-pricing and https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-management-and-organization/information/author-instructions/fees-and-pricing.",
"European Journal of Sociology changes publisher for 2027, so its current Cambridge AI policy may not apply to new submissions: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/european-journal-of-sociology-archives-europeennes-de-sociologie."
]
사회학-organizations — 수수료#
[
"Official journal policies and fee pages inspected for all 18 records; Przegląd Socjologiczny official page was inaccessible via web tool and its prior direct-HTTPS evidence is retained, with a review caveat. Subscription is the reader-access model; optional OA and print color are distinct costs. Cambridge hybrid Gold APC exemption alone does not prove absence of other fees. Network Science waiver depends on funding."
]
사회학-organizations — 지리학#
18개의 기준선 및 발견 후보가 모두 포함되었습니다. 빈 출판사-국가 배열은 출판사가 없는 것이 아니라 확인되지 않은 해당 사무실을 반영합니다. 국제적 범위에서 저자 자격이 추론되지 않습니다.
사회학-organizations — AI 정책#
[
"All 18 baseline and discovery IDs covered. Publisher policies do not establish individual journal exceptions when journal instructions are inaccessible. Sage qualitative-theme analysis restriction is material. Cambridge disclosure wording is not treated by itself as permission."
]
사회학-organizations — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all 18 candidate IDs against the other role files. Independently checked Sage policy, Springer AI guidance and current publisher metrics; Sage drafting ambiguity and Cambridge disclosure-only evidence remain unclear. Fee eligibility and geography assertions were challenged against cited evidence, and uncertainty retained where direct proof was incomplete. This is agent evidence review, not human scientific review.",
"2024 Organizational Research Methods figure is historical; newer official figure was not established. No acceptance-rate inference or difficulty rating is made."
]
[
{
"id": "sociology-organizations-computational-and-mathematical-organization-theory",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "The publisher framework permits supervised interpretive assistance while its FAQ says not to use AI to interpret data; a blanket prohibition misstates the framework and leaves a policy tension.",
"resolution": "Preserve compatible status for permitted research, basic analysis and partial drafting, while stating both clauses and the need to clarify interpretive use."
}
]
공공 정책 — 발견#
[
"All four candidates need independent submission-fee and mandatory-cost verification; hybrid status does not establish absence of other charges. Journal-specific AI policy and publisher applicability require independent audit; International Tax and Public Finance homepage explicitly addresses drafting, data analysis and theoretical proof assistance with disclosure.",
"Rejected Behavioural Public Policy: fully OA with APC and conditional waivers, not an unconditional free route: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/behavioural-public-policy/information/author-instructions/fees-and-pricing and https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/behavioural-public-policy/information/journal-policies/open-access-options."
]
공공 정책 - 수수료#
[
"Independent current audit opened all 18 journal-specific pages or their official editor/publisher alternatives. Some follow-up retrievals timed out or were blocked; historical source evidence is retained and caveated per record. Hybrid no-APC statements alone do not establish zero submission or other mandatory charges."
]
공공 정책 — 지리#
[
"Journal and submission sources were inspected; generic publisher location is not used as a proxy for journal base. PPA author guidelines timed out; eligibility is not asserted. Publisher office countries remain unverified."
]
공공 정책 — AI 정책#
[
"Journal-specific AI policy coverage was not independently verified for all candidates; Springer and Sage publisher guidance is recorded but compatibility remains unclear pending journal-specific review. The three independent university/society venues remain unclear.",
"Cambridge journal-specific pages explicitly contemplate generated text and data analysis with disclosure; no contrary coding restriction was found in the passages inspected."
]
공공 정책 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all 18 merged candidates; official Springer journal homepages independently checked for current 2025 citation metrics for Policy Sciences, Public Organization Review, Public Choice and International Tax and Public Finance. Other retained metrics rely on preceding audits; some Taylor & Francis values derive from search-indexed content with direct access blocked.",
"Reviewed fee and geography audit claims for completeness and internal contradictions; no independent claim of a comprehensive re-audit of each source. Fee eligibility remains conditional or unverified where evidence is incomplete. Journal citation metrics do not indicate acceptance likelihood.",
"Cambridge public-policy author instructions and Springer publisher AI guidance and International Tax and Public Finance journal homepage independently read. AI compatibility and author eligibility are not inferred from mere silence."
]
[
{
"id": "public-policy-journal-of-public-policy",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Existing AI disclosure instructions omit a separate journal instruction requiring disclosure of drafting assistance in the cover letter and acknowledgements.",
"resolution": "Added the journal-specific instruction while retaining other disclosure requirements."
},
{
"id": "public-policy-international-tax-and-public-finance",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "The journal homepage supplies a specific title-page footnote disclosure requirement missing from publisher-only guidance.",
"resolution": "Added journal-specific disclosure; compatibility remains unclear pending confirmation of applicable substantive permission."
}
]
메타 연구 — 발견#
[
"All four journal instructions link Sage AI guidance. Sage permits disclosed generated text, literature assistance and AI-generated research code, subject to human verification; it prohibits generated data and analysis of experiences and themes. AI role must assess applicability and specific restrictions independently.",
"Information Services and Use lists no submission or publication fees but its S2O explanation specifies 2024; present open-access funding model requires verification. Science Communication instructions mention page charges without explaining applicability despite no-fee statement; fee review required.",
"Science, Technology, & Human Values appears elsewhere in the global baseline; this is an additional field membership, not a new venue identity.",
"Excluded Taylor & Francis candidates because publisher policy prohibits first drafts of manuscripts or sections: https://authorservices.taylorandfrancis.com/editorial-policies/using-ai-in-your-research-and-manuscript-preparations/."
]
메타 연구 — 수수료#
[
"Checked each candidate against official venue or publisher material, preserving prior source evidence where still relevant. No inference of free submission from a no-APC statement. Current Research Ethics page was available in official search-indexed text but timed out when opened; historical official PDF conflicts with some boilerplate. Research Synthesis Methods now uses Cambridge OA and conditional funding/waiver, not Wiley hybrid terms."
]
메타 연구 — 지리#
해당 사무소가 독립적으로 설립되지 않은 출판사 국가는 비어 있습니다. 빈 연구 초점은 지리적 영역이 설정되지 않았음을 의미합니다. 국제적 저작자는 명시적인 증거가 있어야만 주장됩니다. 편집자 연락처 및 이전 소유권 증거는 영구 본사를 설립하지 않습니다.
메타 연구 — AI 정책#
17개의 기준선 및 발견 후보가 모두 다루어졌습니다. 직접 HTTP에서 브라우저 액세스가 실패했거나 불완전한 ESTS, European Science Editing 및 Cambridge 준비 페이지를 검색했습니다. Sage 텍스트 생성 공개만으로는 긍정적인 초안 작성 허가가 아닙니다. 저널별 제한이 더 엄격할 수 있습니다. 과학 편집 및 메타심리학 지침에서는 완전한 작업 흐름이 확립되지 않았습니다.
메타 연구 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all 17 IDs and the complete fee, geography and AI-policy output sets. Official current journal pages independently confirm the 2025 Scientometrics impact factors and Oxford journal metrics for Research Evaluation and Science and Public Policy; all previously sourced values preserved with their periods and definitions.",
"Sage policy directly reviewed: permitted literature and code support do not by themselves establish substantive drafting, and the disclosure clause alone is not permission. Sage metrics endpoints for the four newly discovered journals were inaccessible in the browser; no invented figures added.",
"Metrics are journal-level context, not an individual submission acceptance probability. Official indexed Taylor & Francis metrics were previously recorded with direct-page 403 caveat; historical Cambridge rate remains explicitly historical. Independent review is not human scientific review."
]
[
{
"id": "meta-research-scientometrics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Springer permits limited drafting of literature reviews and summaries, analysis assistance, and human verification; it disallows writing an entire manuscript or AI interpretation. This remains conditional and compatible with the specified human-led workflow.",
"resolution": "Retain AI policy and its restrictions; check current journal-specific disclosure wording before submission."
},
{
"id": "meta-research-science-technology-human-values",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Journal explicitly states no submission or publication fees and encourages submissions from all countries; Sage prohibits AI analysis of experiences and themes and gives a disclosure rule for generated text without clearly affirming substantive manuscript drafting.",
"resolution": "Retain verified-free and international geography, but keep AI compatibility unclear pending affirmative drafting evidence."
},
{
"id": "meta-research-research-synthesis-methods",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "A previous-publisher 2023 acceptance rate is historical, not current Cambridge acceptance odds.",
"resolution": "Retain with its year, previous-publisher label and final-decision population; do not portray as current."
},
{
"id": "meta-research-science-communication",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "The fee audit identifies unresolved page-charge language alongside the no-fee statement.",
"resolution": "Keep total author costs unverified until applicability is resolved."
}
]
역학-생물통계학 — 발견#
[
"All AI compatibility, disclosure, geography, submission status and complete fee terms require independent audit; no inference of substantive AI permission is made.",
"Open Statistics source is dated 2021; check journal activity and current fees before inclusion.",
"Epidemiologic Methods publication charge statement is a Harvard founder page and should be checked against present publisher policy.",
"Research Methods in Medicine & Health Sciences author page labels access subscription while describing free access and optional paid open access; preserve uncertainty.",
"Journal of Statistical Software was omitted because it already appears in the global baseline.",
"Journal of Epidemiology excluded: official author guide charges publication fees https://jeaweb.jp/journal/submit/guide_for_authors/index.html ."
]
역학-생물통계학 - 수수료#
[
"All eight candidates audited; zero baseline records were returned by the campaign helper. Direct access to some policies failed; indexed publisher text is marked search_snippet."
]
역학-생물통계학 — 지리학#
[
"Research focus classified International only where the scope expressly says international; missing location or eligibility evidence is not an exclusion. Journal-specific pages and submission instructions were inspected."
]
역학-생물통계학 — AI 정책#
[
"Evidence and permission classifications are conservative; publisher policy may change and journal-specific restrictions override general guidance."
]
전염병학-생물통계학 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all eight discovery records and the three role files. No baseline records or previously sourced metrics were present. Official publisher and society sources were read through web retrieval; inaccessible journal pages are noted per candidate. Citation metrics are journal-level indicators, not acceptance probabilities."
]
[
{
"id": "epidemiology-biostatistics-ebph",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "The cited about page describes an international forum but does not say authors are welcome regardless of geographic location. AI policy contemplates analysis and editing, not substantive drafting.",
"resolution": "Replace author eligibility with not_stated; retain unclear AI compatibility. Journal policy requires a declaration for AI use."
},
{
"id": "epidemiology-biostatistics-epidemiologic-methods",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Publisher author guidance discusses significant generated manuscript content and research design but does not explicitly permit analytical coding or analysis; submission fee remains unconfirmed.",
"resolution": "Retain unclear AI and needs_verification fee status. Publisher journal page reports 2025 citation metrics."
},
{
"id": "epidemiology-biostatistics-open-statistics",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Publisher policy is not an affirmative analytical-code permission; journal author instructions are dated 2021 and current fee terms and submission activity remain uncertain.",
"resolution": "Keep unclear AI and needs_verification; recheck current policy and activity. Journal publisher page was readable, but current fee evidence was not independently established."
},
{
"id": "epidemiology-biostatistics-research-methods-medicine-health-sciences",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Sage instructions explicitly encourage authors from all countries, link the AI policy, and say no APC; they also label access subscription while saying free to view. Submission fees are not expressly settled.",
"resolution": "Keep international eligibility, conditional AI with qualitative-theme restriction, and fee needs_verification."
},
{
"id": "epidemiology-biostatistics-statistical-methods-medical-research",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Journal explicitly says no fees to submit or publish and optional OA and print colour are paid. Sage permits disclosed research code and generated content but prohibits analysis of experiences and themes.",
"resolution": "Retain verified_free standard route and conditional compatible AI, including the stated limitation."
},
{
"id": "epidemiology-biostatistics-biostatistics-epidemiology",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal page returned HTTP 403. Taylor & Francis publisher policy prohibits AI first drafts of manuscripts or sections; journal-specific overrides and all fees could not be independently checked.",
"resolution": "Retain limited AI and needs_verification fees; do not infer geographic author eligibility from the society name."
},
{
"id": "epidemiology-biostatistics-electronic-journal-statistics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "IMS states author or publication fees are not required and donations are voluntary; submission-specific and other charges remain conservatively unresolved. No applicable AI policy established. Historical editorial report includes a partial-cohort rejection estimate rather than acceptance.",
"resolution": "Keep fee needs_verification and AI unclear; report rejection only with cohort, date and unresolved decisions, never infer acceptance."
},
{
"id": "epidemiology-biostatistics-brazilian-journal-biometrics",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Official submission instructions explicitly limit AI to text organization and improvement. About page timed out in this review, so location and broad fee claims could not be independently reread.",
"resolution": "Retain limited AI and needs_verification costs; retain geography provisionally and recheck journal about page."
}
]
환경 공중 보건 — 발견#
[
"These are candidates, not verified free routes or AI-compatible venues. All identified as hybrid on official journal homepages; dedicated independent fee and AI review is required. Springer AI policy must be read and evaluated against the full substantive drafting, research, and analysis requirement.",
"Rejected Environment International: official Elsevier source identifies it as open access, and zero-author-fee route was not established: https://www.sciencedirect.com/author/6701896825/mark-a-j-huijbregts.",
"Current Environmental Health Reports may limit reviews to commissioned contributions; verify before recommendation."
]
환경-공중-보건 — 수수료#
[
"Eight unique discovery candidates audited. The source discovery file repeats IDs already listed by the helper; integration should deduplicate. No submission-fee absence was affirmatively established, so none is marked verified_free."
]
환경-공중-보건 — 지리#
[
"All eight discovery records inspected; helper identified no baseline records. Venue location retained unknown where society or editorial host location was not established. Springer Nature group registered office is recorded separately from the venue."
]
환경-공중-보건 — AI 정책#
[
"All eight discovery journals link to Springer journal policies; no baseline records are present. Publisher guidance permits human-led assistance while prohibiting independent AI authorship and interpretation. Policies may change; recheck at submission."
]
환경 공중 보건 — 지표 검토#
[
"Eight discovery candidates; helper reports no baseline memberships. Official publisher homepages and submission guidelines for each journal, shared subscription policy and research and manuscript AI policies were read. No acceptance rates established. Citation metrics are journal-level and not acceptance probabilities. Environmental Science and Pollution Research current homepage did not display a metric; no historical value was supplied in discovery. No inaccessible source among pages used.",
"The older journal-specific copy-editing disclosure exception conflicts with newer publisher risk guidance; both are recorded without weakening substantive-use disclosure. This is an agent evidence review, not human scientific review."
]
[
{
"id": "environmental-public-health-international-archives-of-occupational-and-environmental-health",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal 420: subscription route has no APC under publisher guidance but submission fees and all compulsory charges remain unverified; scope or publisher location does not establish worldwide author eligibility. Instructions exempt copy editing from disclosure whereas current publisher writing guidance asks for disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and geographic statuses; record disclosure conflict and disclose substantive AI use with methods and human accountability."
},
{
"id": "environmental-public-health-air-quality-atmosphere-and-health",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal 11869: subscription route has no APC under publisher guidance but submission fees and all compulsory charges remain unverified; scope or publisher location does not establish worldwide author eligibility. Instructions exempt copy editing from disclosure whereas current publisher writing guidance asks for disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and geographic statuses; record disclosure conflict and disclose substantive AI use with methods and human accountability."
},
{
"id": "environmental-public-health-environmental-monitoring-and-assessment",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal 10661: subscription route has no APC under publisher guidance but submission fees and all compulsory charges remain unverified; scope or publisher location does not establish worldwide author eligibility. Instructions exempt copy editing from disclosure whereas current publisher writing guidance asks for disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and geographic statuses; record disclosure conflict and disclose substantive AI use with methods and human accountability."
},
{
"id": "environmental-public-health-environmental-geochemistry-and-health",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal 10653: subscription route has no APC under publisher guidance but submission fees and all compulsory charges remain unverified; scope or publisher location does not establish worldwide author eligibility. Instructions exempt copy editing from disclosure whereas current publisher writing guidance asks for disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and geographic statuses; record disclosure conflict and disclose substantive AI use with methods and human accountability."
},
{
"id": "environmental-public-health-exposure-and-health",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal 12403: subscription route has no APC under publisher guidance but submission fees and all compulsory charges remain unverified; scope or publisher location does not establish worldwide author eligibility. Instructions exempt copy editing from disclosure whereas current publisher writing guidance asks for disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and geographic statuses; record disclosure conflict and disclose substantive AI use with methods and human accountability."
},
{
"id": "environmental-public-health-current-environmental-health-reports",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal 40572: subscription route has no APC under publisher guidance but submission fees and all compulsory charges remain unverified; scope or publisher location does not establish worldwide author eligibility. Instructions exempt copy editing from disclosure whereas current publisher writing guidance asks for disclosure. The journal specifies review articles and invited commentaries; it is not a general original-research venue.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and geographic statuses; record disclosure conflict and disclose substantive AI use with methods and human accountability."
},
{
"id": "environmental-public-health-ecohealth",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal 10393: subscription route has no APC under publisher guidance but submission fees and all compulsory charges remain unverified; scope or publisher location does not establish worldwide author eligibility. Instructions exempt copy editing from disclosure whereas current publisher writing guidance asks for disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and geographic statuses; record disclosure conflict and disclose substantive AI use with methods and human accountability."
},
{
"id": "environmental-public-health-environmental-science-and-pollution-research",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal 11356: subscription route has no APC under publisher guidance but submission fees and all compulsory charges remain unverified; scope or publisher location does not establish worldwide author eligibility. Instructions exempt copy editing from disclosure whereas current publisher writing guidance asks for disclosure. Current journal homepage does not display an impact factor; absence is not a zero or acceptance rate.",
"resolution": "Retain conservative fee and geographic statuses; record disclosure conflict and disclose substantive AI use with methods and human accountability."
}
]
건강경제학 — 발견#
[
"AI policy audit must establish full substantive research, code and drafting permission; do not infer compatibility from inclusion here. Springer Nature has broad policy guidance, and EBPH explicitly addresses AI data collection and analysis and manuscript editing; applicability and drafting scope need independent review.",
"Nordic Journal of Health Economics has free submission and publication but currently says it is not accepting submissions: https://journals.uio.no/index.php/NJHE/about/submissions .",
"Value in Health evidence for the subscription route is historical and ScienceDirect current instructions returned 403; treat current costs and policy as unresolved.",
"The Asian Pacific journal AI policy and submission fee need independent verification."
]
건강 경제 - 수수료#
[
"Fee verification is independent of AI policy and submission status. A no-APC subscription route does not establish absence of submission or other charges."
]
건강경제학 - 지리학#
[
"Author geography is not inferred from editorial-board diversity, scope, or a multinational publisher office.",
"International researcher invitation for Asian Pacific Journal is explicitly broad but subject to ordinary scope and editorial requirements."
]
건강경제학 — AI 정책#
[
"All baseline plus discovery records returned by the campaign helper were examined. Publisher guidance must be read alongside any more restrictive journal-specific requirements."
]
건강경제학 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all eight discovery candidates and each completed fee, geography and AI policy file. Citation metrics do not predict individual acceptance. No baseline records exist for this field.",
"Official Wiley journal homepage timed out and Wiley AI guidelines returned HTTP 403; indexed official search content was used only for labeled metric values, not to establish AI compatibility. Journal author instructions were readable.",
"No official citation or acceptance metric was established for Asian Pacific Journal of Health Economics and Policy or Epidemiology, Biostatistics, and Public Health. Source silence is not proof that none exists."
]
[
{
"id": "health-economics-european-journal-of-health-economics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Hybrid subscription route is not proof of free submission or absence of all charges; country of editorial office and author geography remain unestablished. Springer policy supports supervised exploratory analysis and extensive writing with disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification, unknown venue country and not_stated author eligibility; record official citation metrics with year."
},
{
"id": "health-economics-applied-health-economics-and-health-policy",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Hybrid subscription route is not proof of free submission or absence of all charges; country of editorial office and author geography remain unestablished. Springer policy supports supervised exploratory analysis and extensive writing with disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification, unknown venue country and not_stated author eligibility; record official citation metrics with year."
},
{
"id": "health-economics-pharmacoeconomics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Hybrid subscription route is not proof of free submission or absence of all charges; country of editorial office and author geography remain unestablished. Springer policy supports supervised exploratory analysis and extensive writing with disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification, unknown venue country and not_stated author eligibility; record official citation metrics with year."
},
{
"id": "health-economics-health-care-management-science",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Hybrid subscription route is not proof of free submission or absence of all charges; country of editorial office and author geography remain unestablished. Springer policy supports supervised exploratory analysis and extensive writing with disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification, unknown venue country and not_stated author eligibility; record official citation metrics with year."
},
{
"id": "health-economics-health-economics",
"severity": "high",
"issue": "Publisher AI page blocked and the journal instructions establish manuscript development, not research and analysis; compatible designation rested on search snippet. Journal homepage metrics observed only in official indexed search content with no period or denominator.",
"resolution": "Exclude pending readable applicable research and analysis policy; preserve undated metrics with access and denominator limits."
},
{
"id": "health-economics-asian-pacific-journal-of-health-economics-and-policy",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "No-fee statement and no mandatory membership do not separately establish submission charges or every possible mandatory charge; policy does not establish substantive AI permissions.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification and unclear AI; no unsupported metric."
},
{
"id": "health-economics-epidemiology-biostatistics-and-public-health",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Journal explicitly requires no author payments and permits declared data analysis; ethics language describes editing rather than substantive drafting.",
"resolution": "Retain verified_free and unclear AI pending explicit drafting permission; no unsupported metric."
},
{
"id": "health-economics-value-in-health",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Journal expressly prohibits AI drafting for Letters to the Editor; inherited AI record omitted this limitation. Current society instructions describe unpaid non-OA articles, but do not establish all submission or other mandatory charges.",
"resolution": "Add article-type restriction; retain needs_verification for complete cost route and not_stated author eligibility."
}
]
소프트웨어 엔지니어링 — 발견#
[
"All records require independent fee, geography, and substantive AI policy review before inclusion. JOSS explicitly permits most submission uses including software and paper authoring subject to disclosure and human review: https://joss.readthedocs.io/en/latest/policies.html. E-Informatica asks authors to disclose generative AI in manuscript preparation, but that alone does not establish all three required permissions: https://www.e-informatyka.pl/einformatica/authors-guide/paper-requirements-and-recommendations/. Other AI policies remain unverified.",
"The Art, Science, and Engineering of Programming expects presentation at partnering conferences; do not assume a free route before checking registration and alternatives.",
"Global baseline names also present: Journal of Object Technology, e-Informatica Software Engineering Journal, Journal of Statistical Software, Journal of Open Source Software, Logical Methods in Computer Science. Kept because they are relevant to the new software-engineering membership and deduplication must preserve reviewed memberships.",
"JFP moved from Cambridge to its own charity on Episciences in 2026; do not rely on old publisher terms."
]
소프트웨어 엔지니어링 - 수수료#
[
"Eight discovery candidates audited; the helper returned no additional baseline records. Journal fee policies do not establish AI compatibility."
]
소프트웨어 엔지니어링 — 지리#
[
"The JOSS fiscal host is a correspondence address, not a physical office of the online publisher. JFP current editorial or charity location remains unverified. No claim of international author eligibility is inferred from topical scope."
]
소프트웨어 엔지니어링 — AI 정책#
[
"All eight candidates from helper were assessed. No baseline entries were returned separately. Policy silence is uncertainty. ACM policy direct page was blocked; official ACM event reproduces it."
]
소프트웨어 엔지니어링 - 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all eight candidate identities and all fee, geography, and AI policy patches; challenged compatible claims against JOSS and JFP policies, language-only restriction against e-Informatica, and mandatory conference terms against the Programming agreement. Author eligibility remains not stated throughout.",
"Official venue metrics searches found no sufficiently specific reported acceptance rates for these records; empty arrays do not imply zero citations or easy acceptance. JFP direct ACM policy was blocked; the other auditor reports reading an official ACM reproduction. Review is agent evidence review, not human scientific review."
]
[
{
"id": "software-engineering-art-science-engineering-programming",
"severity": "high",
"issue": "Publication agreement requires conference registration and presentation; a zero journal fee alone is insufficient.",
"resolution": "Retain fees auditor not_free classification and dated conference rate, subject to future rates."
},
{
"id": "software-engineering-e-informatica",
"severity": "high",
"issue": "Writing policy limits generative AI to language and readability.",
"resolution": "Retain limited compatibility and exclude from the AI-compatible main directory."
},
{
"id": "software-engineering-journal-functional-programming",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Publisher changed in 2026; submission costs remain unconfirmed and direct ACM page was inaccessible.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification route and linked adoption plus official ACM reproduction evidence; recheck current policy and fee before submitting."
},
{
"id": "software-engineering-journal-open-source-software",
"severity": "low",
"issue": "Software-specific permission and mandatory disclosure must accompany compatibility; author geography is not established.",
"resolution": "Retain conditional permissions, required disclosure, and not_stated author eligibility."
}
]
사이버 보안 - 개인 정보 보호 - 검색#
[
"Fee eligibility is provisional across all candidates; substantive AI compatibility requires independent journal-specific audit.",
"Rejected Organizational Cybersecurity Journal despite diamond funding: Emerald policy prohibits generative AI for generating, manipulating or reporting research data and results (https://www.emeraldgrouppublishing.com/publish-with-us/ethics-integrity/research-publishing-ethics).",
"Rejected Journal of Cybersecurity and Privacy (MDPI), whose homepage states authors or institutions pay APCs: https://www.mdpi.com/journal/jcp.",
"No conference registration is assumed free. The Indonesian and Universiti Malaya journals are recent; assess maturity and policy applicability."
]
사이버 보안 - 개인 정보 보호 — 수수료#
[
"No baseline memberships exist for this new subfield; audited all eight discovery candidates returned by the campaign helper.",
"Fee audit does not assess AI compatibility."
]
사이버 보안 - 개인 정보 보호 — 지리#
저널 기반은 일반 출판사 본사를 따르지 않습니다. 일반적인 국제 범위 자체가 전 세계 저자 자격을 확립하지는 않습니다.
사이버 보안 - 개인 정보 보호 — AI 정책#
[
"Baseline plus discovery helper yielded eight unique records at audit time. Disclosure alone is not permission.",
"Computers & Security guide blocked; applicable publisher policy is readable, but journal-specific restrictions could not be independently ruled out."
]
사이버 보안-개인정보 — 지표-검토#
[
"Reviewed all eight discovery IDs, fee, geography and AI role patches. Official publisher metrics located for Wiley journal; absence of a metric does not mean none exists.",
"Independent source inspection included Sage and Elsevier AI policies and Wiley journal metrics; other role evidence was critically reviewed. No subjective difficulty bands."
]
[
{
"id": "cybersecurity-privacy-computers-security",
"severity": "material",
"issue": "Journal-specific author instructions blocked and cited fee page ownership unconfirmed. Publisher-wide AI policy alone does not eliminate possible journal-specific restrictions.",
"resolution": "Set AI compatibility unclear and publication fee unknown pending accessible official journal policy."
},
{
"id": "cybersecurity-privacy-privacy-confidentiality",
"severity": "material",
"issue": "Current policy states $500 per accepted manuscript, superseding historical no-fee evidence.",
"resolution": "Retain not_free route and exclude from free directory."
},
{
"id": "cybersecurity-privacy-computer-security",
"severity": "informational",
"issue": "Sage permits research code and primary or partial generated content with disclosure, but prohibits qualitative analysis of experiences and themes.",
"resolution": "Retain compatible classification for permitted workflows and preserve specific restrictions and disclosure."
},
{
"id": "cybersecurity-privacy-security-privacy-wiley",
"severity": "informational",
"issue": "Publisher journal page reports undated 2.9 impact factor and 19% acceptance rate without denominator.",
"resolution": "Retain as undated reported figures without implying personal acceptance probability."
}
]
인간-컴퓨터 상호작용 — 발견#
[
"Independent AI policy review required for all. JHTR requires human-generated ideas, interpretations and conclusions and specifies disclosures in methods, an AI section and cover letter; adjudicate against the founder workflow.",
"ACM proceedings in 2026 normally incur APCs unless institution or conference covers them or an eligible waiver applies. Registration is a separate cost: https://www.acm.org/binaries/content/assets/sigs/conference-planning-guide/acms-transition-to-full-open-access.pdf",
"Sage editorial guidance discusses generative writing, but is insufficient by itself to establish all required uses; journal-specific limitations apply: https://www.sagepub.com/journals/information-for-editors/editor-guide-to-sage-editorial-publishing-policies",
"Rejected lead IxD&A requires a compulsory donation without a stated lower limit: https://ixdea.org/."
]
인간-컴퓨터 상호 작용 — 수수료#
[
"The discovery file currently repeats the eight baseline IDs rather than listing additional venues; patches cover every distinct candidate returned by the helper.",
"No conference registration fee is inferred for the CLEI journal; separate conference participation can incur charges."
]
인간-컴퓨터 상호작용 — 지리#
[
"All eight unique candidate IDs from the helper were reviewed. Journal base, publisher location, research remit and author eligibility are distinct. Empty country arrays indicate unestablished location."
]
인간-컴퓨터 상호작용 — AI 정책#
[
"Permission classifications reflect policy scope; silence or a disclosure requirement alone is not permission."
]
인간-컴퓨터 상호작용 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Eight discovery candidates and zero baseline records reviewed. No verified numeric acceptance or citation metric located in official material reviewed; empty metrics are not evidence of low selectivity.",
"Independently challenged fee, AI disclosure, and geography fields; retained unknowns where the source does not affirm eligibility.",
"AI classification evaluates the founder workflow, not independent human scientific or venue acceptance review."
]
[
{
"id": "human-computer-interaction-avances-en-interaccion-humano-computadora",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Broad AI manuscript preparation and explicit AI-generated analysis/code scope require semantic interpretation.",
"resolution": "Retain compatible conditional permissions with tool, role, accuracy and human responsibility disclosures; this does not allow AI authorship."
},
{
"id": "human-computer-interaction-clei-electronic-journal",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee review did not identify the owning society explicit free-submission statement.",
"resolution": "Replace complete route with source-backed verified_free status."
}
]
로봇 제어 — 발견#
[
"Fee status remains needs_verification: lack of an APC is not proof of free submission or absence of mandatory page charges. AI policy compatibility requires independent journal-specific review. Springer journal guidance requires LLM-use disclosure and distinguishes copyediting from generative work, but this alone does not establish all required permissions: https://link.springer.com/journal/43684/submission-guidelines.",
"Rejected Journal of Intelligent & Robotic Systems: now fully OA with APC, https://link.springer.com/journal/10846/how-to-publish-with-us. Rejected Nonlinear Dynamics: all submissions from 11 August 2026 subject to APC unless waiver, https://link.springer.com/journal/11071.",
"IEEE Transactions on Robotics and IEEE Transactions on Automation Science and Engineering impose mandatory overlength charges, respectively https://www.ieee-ras.org/publications/t-ro/t-ro-information-for-authors/ and https://www.ieee-ras.org/publications/t-ase/frequently-asked-questions/. Membership, standard length and conference registration require venue-specific verification. No conference route inferred free.",
"Elsevier journal pages were read via official indexed page content; direct web opening returned 403. Journal-specific AI and all cost conditions remain to be audited."
]
로봇 제어 — 수수료#
[
"All nine discovery records and zero baseline records audited. Springer journal fee pages and submission guidelines read directly; ScienceDirect pages were blocked, so Elsevier journal claims use official indexed snippets. No conferences in this field; registration is not applicable. Verified-free requires affirmative proof of both submission and publication at no cost."
]
로봇 제어 — 지리#
9개의 발견 후보가 확인되었습니다. 일반 Springer 지원 페이지에서는 저널 사무실을 식별하지 않습니다. 차단된 Elsevier 페이지로 인해 작성자 자격이 불분명해집니다. 게시자 위치가 확인되지 않았으며 비어 있습니다. 알 수 없는 지역적 소관은 저자 제한이 아닙니다.
로봇 제어 — AI 정책#
[
"All nine discovery candidates inspected. Elsevier journal guides returned HTTP 403 and author factsheet conflicts with publisher policy on substantive text; conservative unclear classification retained."
]
로봇 제어 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all nine discovery IDs and completed role files; baseline has no records in this field. Official Springer journal pages and publisher AI guidance read; ScienceDirect indexed official content accessible but direct journal guides blocked. Citation metrics do not measure acceptance probability. Elsevier metrics omitted because indexed values are undated or conflicting. No independently reported acceptance rate established.",
"AI interpretation follows the campaign semantic rule: explicitly permitted basic analysis and drafting literature reviews or summaries meet the human-led workflow with disclosure; complete autonomous manuscript writing is not required."
]
[
{
"id": "robotics-control-autonomous-intelligent-systems",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee evidence does not verify all mandatory author charges; author geography is not affirmatively established.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification and geographic uncertainty."
},
{
"id": "robotics-control-autonomous-robots",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee evidence does not verify all mandatory author charges; author geography is not affirmatively established.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification and geographic uncertainty."
},
{
"id": "robotics-control-international-journal-social-robotics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee evidence does not verify all mandatory author charges; author geography is not affirmatively established.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification and geographic uncertainty."
},
{
"id": "robotics-control-international-journal-control-automation-systems",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee evidence does not verify all mandatory author charges; author geography is not affirmatively established.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification and geographic uncertainty."
},
{
"id": "robotics-control-international-journal-dynamics-control",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee evidence does not verify all mandatory author charges; author geography is not affirmatively established.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification and geographic uncertainty."
},
{
"id": "robotics-control-international-journal-intelligent-robotics-applications",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee evidence does not verify all mandatory author charges; author geography is not affirmatively established.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification and geographic uncertainty."
},
{
"id": "robotics-control-discrete-event-dynamic-systems",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Journal explicitly states no submission or publication fee; short paper length and optional charges remain conditions.",
"resolution": "Retain verified_free for documented standard route and conditions."
},
{
"id": "robotics-control-robotics-autonomous-systems",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee evidence does not verify all mandatory author charges; author geography is not affirmatively established.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification and geographic uncertainty."
},
{
"id": "robotics-control-robotics-autonomous-systems",
"severity": "warning",
"issue": "Elsevier factsheet and policy differ on substantive writing; journal-specific guide blocked.",
"resolution": "Retain unclear AI compatibility pending resolution."
},
{
"id": "robotics-control-journal-franklin-institute",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Fee evidence does not verify all mandatory author charges; author geography is not affirmatively established.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification and geographic uncertainty."
},
{
"id": "robotics-control-journal-franklin-institute",
"severity": "warning",
"issue": "Elsevier factsheet and policy differ on substantive writing; journal-specific guide blocked.",
"resolution": "Retain unclear AI compatibility pending resolution."
},
{
"id": "robotics-control-journal-franklin-institute",
"severity": "warning",
"issue": "Official indexed pages show differing undated Impact Factor values (4.2 and 3.7), with no metric year established.",
"resolution": "Do not select either as current; metrics remain empty pending dated confirmation."
}
]
에너지-환경-공학 — 발견#
[
"Eight candidate journals; fee and AI policy require independent role audits. Indexed Royal Society of Chemistry policy permits disclosed GenAI drafting, code refinement and visualization but does not by itself resolve every substantive research and analysis use; AI compatibility must not be assumed. https://www.rsc.org/publishing/journals/processes-and-policies/author-responsibilities",
"RSC direct pages returned HTTP 403; indexed official text explicitly states no submission or publication fee for five titles. Ancillary fees and direct current page verification remain outstanding. Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts and Environmental Modelling & Software are provisional leads with fee evidence unresolved.",
"Excluded paid-only Journal of Physics: Energy and Environmental Research: Energy; neither discounted APCs nor institutional agreements establish unconditional free publication. https://publishingsupport.iopscience.iop.org/journals/journal-of-physics-energy/about-journal-physics-energy/ https://publishingsupport.iopscience.iop.org/journals/environmental-research-energy/about-environmental-research-energy/",
"Progress in Energy allows review proposals but requires advance outline; do not interpret review availability as automatic."
]
에너지-환경-엔지니어링 — 수수료#
8개의 도우미 기록을 모두 검사했습니다. RSC 저널 및 일반 정책 텍스트는 공식 색인 검색 콘텐츠에서 제공되었지만 직접 액세스하면 403이 반환되었습니다. 구독 약관에는 필수 멤버십이 명시되어 있지 않습니다. 환경 모델링 및 소프트웨어에는 직접 요금 확인이 필요합니다.
에너지-환경-공학 — 지리#
[
"All eight discovery records inspected. Official indexed RSC pages were available, but direct retrieval of several journal/author pages and both Elsevier journal pages was blocked; location and author eligibility remain conservative."
]
에너지-환경-엔지니어링 — AI 정책#
[
"All eight records returned by campaign helper audited. Official RSC indexed text was available but direct policy pages returned 403; Elsevier journal-specific guide returned 403. These seven records remain unclear pending readable journal-specific evidence."
]
에너지-환경-엔지니어링 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Eight discovery candidates and no baseline memberships; audited all eight against completed fees, geography, and AI policy. RSC official indexed content is weaker than directly readable policy; six verified-free fee claims were demoted. IOP policy read directly and supports the stated compatible classification. Elsevier remains unclear pending journal-specific terms. Journal-level impact factors do not predict manuscript acceptance. No official acceptance rates were established."
]
[
{
"id": "energy-environmental-engineering-energy-and-environmental-science",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Verified-free eligibility depends on official search-indexed content while direct publisher policy pages returned 403; full current terms and compulsory costs cannot be independently checked.",
"resolution": "Demoted to needs_verification and retained the indexed fee evidence; verify readable official terms before recommendation."
},
{
"id": "energy-environmental-engineering-sustainable-energy-and-fuels",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Verified-free eligibility depends on official search-indexed content while direct publisher policy pages returned 403; full current terms and compulsory costs cannot be independently checked.",
"resolution": "Demoted to needs_verification and retained the indexed fee evidence; verify readable official terms before recommendation."
},
{
"id": "energy-environmental-engineering-journal-of-materials-chemistry-a",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Verified-free eligibility depends on official search-indexed content while direct publisher policy pages returned 403; full current terms and compulsory costs cannot be independently checked.",
"resolution": "Demoted to needs_verification and retained the indexed fee evidence; verify readable official terms before recommendation."
},
{
"id": "energy-environmental-engineering-environmental-science-water-research-and-technology",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Verified-free eligibility depends on official search-indexed content while direct publisher policy pages returned 403; full current terms and compulsory costs cannot be independently checked.",
"resolution": "Demoted to needs_verification and retained the indexed fee evidence; verify readable official terms before recommendation."
},
{
"id": "energy-environmental-engineering-environmental-science-processes-and-impacts",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Verified-free eligibility depends on official search-indexed content while direct publisher policy pages returned 403; full current terms and compulsory costs cannot be independently checked.",
"resolution": "Demoted to needs_verification and retained the indexed fee evidence; verify readable official terms before recommendation."
},
{
"id": "energy-environmental-engineering-environmental-science-nano",
"severity": "medium",
"issue": "Verified-free eligibility depends on official search-indexed content while direct publisher policy pages returned 403; full current terms and compulsory costs cannot be independently checked.",
"resolution": "Demoted to needs_verification and retained the indexed fee evidence; verify readable official terms before recommendation."
},
{
"id": "energy-environmental-engineering-progress-in-energy",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Directly readable IOP journal policy confirms no subscription publication, submission or other publishing charges. IOP AI policy expressly permits research, analysis/code and critically revised generated text with disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retained verified-free route and compatible AI classification. The metrics link did not yield a verified numerical figure."
},
{
"id": "energy-environmental-engineering-environmental-modelling-and-software",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Elsevier journal-specific fees and AI policy were inaccessible, and the publisher notes journal-specific AI variation. Author location eligibility is not affirmed.",
"resolution": "Retained needs_verification fees and unclear AI classification; publisher metric is included as undated."
}
]
통계-응용-수학 — 발견#
[
"All records require independent fee, geography, and AI policy review. AI compatibility is not inferred from silence. Lithuanian Journal of Statistics explicitly addresses writing and data collection/analysis AI use in its journal policy; its full applicability still requires dedicated review.",
"IMS explicitly characterizes contributions as voluntary, notwithstanding amounts displayed on its funding form: https://imstat.org/shop/publication-charge-funding-form/. Do not generalize this to other IMS journals.",
"Open Statistics instructions are dated 2021; verify current terms and operational status before relying on them. AADM does not expressly establish a zero submission fee on the inspected page.",
"Journal of Statistical Software already appears in the baseline and was not repeated. Excluded Journal of Applied Mathematics (Wiley): official policy specifies an article publication charge https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/page/journal/4185/homepage/open-access ."
]
통계-응용-수학 — 수수료#
[
"IMS direct fetch returned 502; search service returned full text of official journal pages. Explicit author-fee prohibition covers mandatory author charges; payment form is voluntary per each journal.",
"Current proof for all mandatory costs remains incomplete for Lithuanian Journal of Statistics, AADM, and Open Statistics; dated policy is labeled."
]
통계-응용-수학 — 지리#
[
"IMS co-sponsorship does not by itself establish a unique journal base. Country and publisher fields remain empty where exact bases were not established. General international scope does not alone establish author eligibility."
]
통계-응용-수학 — AI 정책#
[
"Official IMS AI policy blocked by bot challenge and web 502; secondary descriptions are not treated as verified permission. Policies can change; check before submission."
]
통계-응용-수학 — 측정항목-검토#
[
"Reviewed all eight merged candidates. IMS official AI policy ordinary direct HTTPS returned HTTP 200 bot challenge rather than the policy; web retrieval failed. Inaccessible evidence is not evidence of prohibition or permission.",
"No acceptance rates or additional official current metrics established in this review. Empty metric arrays reflect no verified figure, not absence of a metric. Geography distinguishes venue from publisher; no additional geography correction established.",
"Fee claims for the five IMS journals rest on search-rendered evidence; retain uncertainty until complete official submission and other mandatory charges are independently established. Lithuanian and Open Statistics fee limitations and Serbian submission-fee uncertainty remain."
]
[
{
"id": "statistics-applied-mathematics-electronic-journal-of-probability",
"severity": "moderate",
"issue": "Verified-free classification relied on search-rendered fee evidence and does not independently establish all submission-stage and other compulsory charges. IMS AI policy returned bot challenge via direct HTTPS and web access failed.",
"resolution": "Demoted to needs_verification; retain AI unclear and verify full policy and fees before recommendation."
},
{
"id": "statistics-applied-mathematics-electronic-communications-in-probability",
"severity": "moderate",
"issue": "Verified-free classification relied on search-rendered fee evidence and does not independently establish all submission-stage and other compulsory charges. IMS AI policy returned bot challenge via direct HTTPS and web access failed.",
"resolution": "Demoted to needs_verification; retain AI unclear and verify full policy and fees before recommendation."
},
{
"id": "statistics-applied-mathematics-electronic-journal-of-statistics",
"severity": "moderate",
"issue": "Verified-free classification relied on search-rendered fee evidence and does not independently establish all submission-stage and other compulsory charges. IMS AI policy returned bot challenge via direct HTTPS and web access failed.",
"resolution": "Demoted to needs_verification; retain AI unclear and verify full policy and fees before recommendation."
},
{
"id": "statistics-applied-mathematics-statistics-surveys",
"severity": "moderate",
"issue": "Verified-free classification relied on search-rendered fee evidence and does not independently establish all submission-stage and other compulsory charges. IMS AI policy returned bot challenge via direct HTTPS and web access failed.",
"resolution": "Demoted to needs_verification; retain AI unclear and verify full policy and fees before recommendation."
},
{
"id": "statistics-applied-mathematics-probability-surveys",
"severity": "moderate",
"issue": "Verified-free classification relied on search-rendered fee evidence and does not independently establish all submission-stage and other compulsory charges. IMS AI policy returned bot challenge via direct HTTPS and web access failed.",
"resolution": "Demoted to needs_verification; retain AI unclear and verify full policy and fees before recommendation."
},
{
"id": "statistics-applied-mathematics-lithuanian-journal-of-statistics",
"severity": "moderate",
"issue": "AI auditor treated absence of the literal word code as excluding expressly addressed data analysis.",
"resolution": "Mark analysis_code conditional and compatible using the contract semantic rule; preserve required disclosure and responsibility. Fees remain needs_verification."
},
{
"id": "statistics-applied-mathematics-open-statistics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Publisher policy describes study methodology and AI-generated code generally but also prohibits creation or manipulation of research data; it does not explicitly permit data analysis under that restriction.",
"resolution": "Retain unclear AI compatibility and fee uncertainty; do not infer analytical permission from disclosure or a generic definition of tools."
}
]
교육-학습-과학 — 발견#
[
"All records are leads requiring independent full fee and AI-policy review. Policy permission for manuscript assistance alone does not establish compatibility with substantive research and analysis/code.",
"The Indonesian Journal of Informatics Education explicitly describes research and writing AI use in its editorial policy; scope and any restrictions require careful audit.",
"PUP explicitly addresses manuscript writing AI disclosure, but analysis/code permission remains unverified.",
"Sage guidelines establish a free standard publishing route; publisher AI policy and journal applicability need independent review.",
"Excluded Yıldız Journal of Educational Research: official policy describes language correction and improvement, insufficient to establish substantive workflow permission: https://dergipark.org.tr/en/pub/yjer/issue/106241."
]
교육-학습-과학 — 수수료#
[
"PUP submission-fee source was accessible only as a search snippet; direct page retrieval timed out. Sage journal-specific PDF instructions were read; optional services do not change the standard route."
]
교육-학습-과학 — 지리#
Campaign_records 도우미가 반환한 모든 후보자를 검사했습니다. 공식 페이지가 더 이상 입증되지 않는 경우 알 수 없는 위치와 자격이 유지됩니다. 세이지 사무소는 명시적으로 출판사 위치에만 해당됩니다.
교육-학습-과학 — AI 정책#
8명의 도우미 후보 모두 저널별 공식 지침과 해당 출판사 정책에 따라 감사를 받았습니다. 호환성은 모든 AI 사용에 대한 포괄적인 승인이 아니라 명시된 제한 내에서 사람이 주도하는 워크플로를 설명합니다.
교육-학습-과학 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all eight candidates. Journal statistics are not manuscript acceptance probabilities. No acceptance rate was independently verified. Accessible Sage policy, IJIE policy, RAIE ethics and statistics, and JRET about page read directly; PUP author guidelines timed out. Fee and geography conclusions are bounded by the cited individual role evidence."
]
[
{
"id": "education-learning-sciences-indonesian-journal-informatics-education",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "The journal explicitly states a worldwide no-fee route and permits human-revised drafting and verified data-analysis assistance, but the checklist caps AI-generated text at 12%.",
"resolution": "Retain compatible conditional workflow and disclose the quantitative limit."
},
{
"id": "education-learning-sciences-review-artificial-intelligence-education",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "The journal states a worldwide no-fee policy and addresses AI use for writing, collection, and analysis with human oversight. Its journal-wide citation count is a snapshot, not acceptance probability.",
"resolution": "Retain compatible conditional workflow and label citation snapshot."
},
{
"id": "education-learning-sciences-research-education-teaching",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Official policy confirms no-fee processing but limits AI to supportive language functions; location and author eligibility remain unestablished.",
"resolution": "Retain prohibited classification and unknown geography."
},
{
"id": "education-learning-sciences-pup-education-review",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "The author-guidelines URL timed out on independent web retrieval; the fee reviewer reports a snippet while the AI reviewer reports a successful page read. Disclosure alone cannot establish substantive permission.",
"resolution": "Retain needs_verification fee and unclear AI classifications pending readable policy verification."
},
{
"id": "education-learning-sciences-journal-management-education",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Sage permits generated research code and conditional generated text with disclosure, but prohibits AI analysis of experiences and themes. The journal gives a first-decision average without a period or denominator.",
"resolution": "Retain qualified AI compatibility and label timing limits; do not infer acceptance rate."
},
{
"id": "education-learning-sciences-journal-transformative-education",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Sage permits generated research code and conditional generated text with disclosure, but prohibits AI analysis of experiences and themes. Sage offices do not establish journal location.",
"resolution": "Retain qualified AI compatibility and unknown venue base."
},
{
"id": "education-learning-sciences-culture-and-education",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "The Spanish foundation location is supported by a historical 2020 editorial; it should not imply an independently reverified current operational office. Sage limits AI analysis of experiences and themes.",
"resolution": "Retain dated foundation basis and conditional compatibility; label 2018 impact factor historical."
},
{
"id": "education-learning-sciences-theory-research-education",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Sage permits generated research code and conditional generated text with disclosure, but prohibits AI analysis of experiences and themes. Publisher offices do not establish the journal base.",
"resolution": "Retain qualified AI compatibility and unknown venue base."
}
]
정치과학 — 발견#
[
"These are candidates for independent fee, geography, and AI-policy audit; no compatibility conclusion is made here. Current Sage policy explicitly permits disclosed AI-generated research code but prohibits AI analysis of experiences and themes and certain generated data; policy restrictions must be respected.",
"AI, Law, Politics was established in 2025 and has a focused institutional governance scope."
]
정치학 - 수수료#
[
"Sage journal-specific explicit submission and publication statements and publisher charge list reviewed; recheck charges before submitting."
]
정치 과학 - 지리학#
[
"European Union Politics venue country remains unknown pending specific ownership or editorial-office evidence. Sage office locations are explicitly offices, not necessarily the publishing entity for an individual journal."
]
정치과학 - AI 정책#
[
"Sage explicitly prohibits prompt-generated submissions and analysis of experiences and themes while allowing specified research and code assistance with disclosure. Partial manuscript drafting boundaries remain unclear; seven directly linked journals classified limited and International Studies unclear pending direct policy applicability."
]
정치 과학 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Reviewed all nine baseline and discovery candidates against all three helper files. Journal-specific Sage instructions explicitly state no submission or publication fee; optional OA is separate. Seven instructions affirm worldwide submissions; International Studies instructions lack the shared policy passage and its society evidence is less direct.",
"VIZJA journal policy explicitly covers generative text, code, data and analysis and disclosure placement; no evidence supports a country restriction. Its official author fees page https://alp-journal.com/index.php/journal/author-fees-and-charges corroborates zero submission, publication, page and colour charges.",
"Sage publisher policy https://www.sagepub.com/journals/publication-ethics-policies/artificial-intelligence-policy lists restricted prompt generation and thematic analysis; all eight remain excluded.",
"Official 2025 JCR figures and 2024 acceptance figures for three PSA titles are included. Other six metrics remain empty; the source does not identify acceptance denominators. Source report is marked draft."
]
[
{
"id": "political-science-political-studies",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Sage policy permits disclosed research and code uses but restricts prompt-generated submissions and thematic analysis; partial drafting boundary is unclear.",
"resolution": "Retain limited or unclear status and exclude from main directory; do not infer drafting permission."
},
{
"id": "political-science-international-relations",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Sage policy permits disclosed research and code uses but restricts prompt-generated submissions and thematic analysis; partial drafting boundary is unclear.",
"resolution": "Retain limited or unclear status and exclude from main directory; do not infer drafting permission."
},
{
"id": "political-science-politics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Sage policy permits disclosed research and code uses but restricts prompt-generated submissions and thematic analysis; partial drafting boundary is unclear.",
"resolution": "Retain limited or unclear status and exclude from main directory; do not infer drafting permission."
},
{
"id": "political-science-comparative-political-studies",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Sage policy permits disclosed research and code uses but restricts prompt-generated submissions and thematic analysis; partial drafting boundary is unclear.",
"resolution": "Retain limited or unclear status and exclude from main directory; do not infer drafting permission."
},
{
"id": "political-science-studies-in-indian-politics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Sage policy permits disclosed research and code uses but restricts prompt-generated submissions and thematic analysis; partial drafting boundary is unclear.",
"resolution": "Retain limited or unclear status and exclude from main directory; do not infer drafting permission."
},
{
"id": "political-science-european-union-politics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Sage policy permits disclosed research and code uses but restricts prompt-generated submissions and thematic analysis; partial drafting boundary is unclear.",
"resolution": "Retain limited or unclear status and exclude from main directory; do not infer drafting permission."
},
{
"id": "political-science-international-studies",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Sage policy permits disclosed research and code uses but restricts prompt-generated submissions and thematic analysis; partial drafting boundary is unclear.",
"resolution": "Retain limited or unclear status and exclude from main directory; do not infer drafting permission."
},
{
"id": "political-science-the-british-journal-of-politics-and-international-relations",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Sage policy permits disclosed research and code uses but restricts prompt-generated submissions and thematic analysis; partial drafting boundary is unclear.",
"resolution": "Retain limited or unclear status and exclude from main directory; do not infer drafting permission."
},
{
"id": "political-science-ai-law-politics",
"severity": "info",
"issue": "Independent check of journal declarations and ethics supports conditional AI-assisted text, code, data and analysis, with substantial human intellectual contribution and disclosure.",
"resolution": "Retain compatible with stated restrictions; journal fee schedule confirms no author charges and identifies Warsaw publisher. Geographic author eligibility remains not stated."
}
]
비즈니스 혁신 — 발견#
[
"Official Elsevier AI policy describes research-use methods disclosure and manuscript-preparation disclosure with human responsibility; journal-specific applicability and restrictions must be independently checked. Earlier Elsevier guidance restricts writing to readability and language, so the currently applicable instructions and conflict require close audit.",
"Official journal homepages returned HTTP 403 in this discovery session. Subscription route and all compulsory fees are unknown, not verified free; third-party leads suggested a free subscription route for Research Policy, Technovation, Technology in Society and European Management Journal but are not sufficient fee evidence.",
"Schmalenbach Journal of Business Research excluded: official editorial states APCs apply, https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s41471-021-00112-w. No claimed peer-review status or confirmed journal-specific AI permission pending audit."
]
비즈니스 혁신 - 수수료#
8명의 후보자가 감사를 받았습니다. 모든 저널별 수수료 페이지가 차단되었습니다. verify_free에 대한 증거 임계값을 충족하는 기록이 없습니다. 출판사 정책에는 제출 비용이 저널마다 다르다고 명시되어 있습니다.
비즈니스 혁신 — 지리#
[
"All eight ScienceDirect journal aims/scope and author-guide pages returned HTTP 403. Publisher headquarters is separate from unverified journal bases. Historical journal-hosted articles support the noted broad focus, not current eligibility."
]
비즈니스 혁신 - AI 정책#
8개 후보 모두 Elsevier 저널입니다. 출판사 전체 저널 정책은 요청된 사람 주도 작업 흐름을 지원하지만 8개의 특정 저자 가이드 모두 403을 반환했습니다. 저널별 제한 사항을 확인할 때까지 호환성은 불분명합니다. 리뷰어 기밀 제한은 저자 금지를 설정하지 않습니다.
비즈니스 혁신 — 측정항목 검토#
[
"Independently checked Elsevier journal policy and official publisher metrics listing through web retrieval. Publisher policy requires a manuscript declaration before references and reproducible methods reporting for research uses; basic spelling/grammar/punctuation checks are excepted. Specific guide applicability and any stricter journal policy remain unresolved.",
"Metrics are undated publisher display values and cannot be assigned a reporting year from the listing. No acceptance rate or editorial difficulty inferred. Two journals have no metrics because an adequately current official source was not established.",
"This is an agent evidence review, not human scientific review."
]
[
{
"id": "business-innovation-research-policy",
"severity": "uncertainty",
"issue": "Author guide inaccessible, so journal-specific AI restrictions, complete mandatory charges and geographic eligibility remain unverified. General publisher policy is explicit on human-led research, analysis and supported manuscript preparation with disclosure, but local overrides remain unknown.",
"resolution": "Retain unclear AI compatibility and needs_verification fees; preserve unknown author eligibility and location. Confirm the journal guide before inclusion or submission."
},
{
"id": "business-innovation-technovation",
"severity": "uncertainty",
"issue": "Author guide inaccessible, so journal-specific AI restrictions, complete mandatory charges and geographic eligibility remain unverified. General publisher policy is explicit on human-led research, analysis and supported manuscript preparation with disclosure, but local overrides remain unknown.",
"resolution": "Retain unclear AI compatibility and needs_verification fees; preserve unknown author eligibility and location. Confirm the journal guide before inclusion or submission."
},
{
"id": "business-innovation-technology-in-society",
"severity": "uncertainty",
"issue": "Author guide inaccessible, so journal-specific AI restrictions, complete mandatory charges and geographic eligibility remain unverified. General publisher policy is explicit on human-led research, analysis and supported manuscript preparation with disclosure, but local overrides remain unknown.",
"resolution": "Retain unclear AI compatibility and needs_verification fees; preserve unknown author eligibility and location. Confirm the journal guide before inclusion or submission."
},
{
"id": "business-innovation-technological-forecasting-and-social-change",
"severity": "uncertainty",
"issue": "Author guide inaccessible, so journal-specific AI restrictions, complete mandatory charges and geographic eligibility remain unverified. General publisher policy is explicit on human-led research, analysis and supported manuscript preparation with disclosure, but local overrides remain unknown.",
"resolution": "Retain unclear AI compatibility and needs_verification fees; preserve unknown author eligibility and location. Confirm the journal guide before inclusion or submission."
},
{
"id": "business-innovation-european-management-journal",
"severity": "uncertainty",
"issue": "Author guide inaccessible, so journal-specific AI restrictions, complete mandatory charges and geographic eligibility remain unverified. General publisher policy is explicit on human-led research, analysis and supported manuscript preparation with disclosure, but local overrides remain unknown.",
"resolution": "Retain unclear AI compatibility and needs_verification fees; preserve unknown author eligibility and location. Confirm the journal guide before inclusion or submission."
},
{
"id": "business-innovation-journal-of-business-research",
"severity": "uncertainty",
"issue": "Author guide inaccessible, so journal-specific AI restrictions, complete mandatory charges and geographic eligibility remain unverified. General publisher policy is explicit on human-led research, analysis and supported manuscript preparation with disclosure, but local overrides remain unknown.",
"resolution": "Retain unclear AI compatibility and needs_verification fees; preserve unknown author eligibility and location. Confirm the journal guide before inclusion or submission."
},
{
"id": "business-innovation-industrial-marketing-management",
"severity": "uncertainty",
"issue": "Author guide inaccessible, so journal-specific AI restrictions, complete mandatory charges and geographic eligibility remain unverified. General publisher policy is explicit on human-led research, analysis and supported manuscript preparation with disclosure, but local overrides remain unknown.",
"resolution": "Retain unclear AI compatibility and needs_verification fees; preserve unknown author eligibility and location. Confirm the journal guide before inclusion or submission."
},
{
"id": "business-innovation-journal-of-engineering-and-technology-management",
"severity": "uncertainty",
"issue": "Author guide inaccessible, so journal-specific AI restrictions, complete mandatory charges and geographic eligibility remain unverified. General publisher policy is explicit on human-led research, analysis and supported manuscript preparation with disclosure, but local overrides remain unknown.",
"resolution": "Retain unclear AI compatibility and needs_verification fees; preserve unknown author eligibility and location. Confirm the journal guide before inclusion or submission."
}
]